| Rank | Name | Main Team | Years | Season | Fantasy | Playoffs | Rating | Overall |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tom Brady | Patriots | 23 | Elite | Elite | Elite | 148.5 | Aura |
| 2 | Joe Montana | 49ers | 15 | Great | Great | Elite | 86.6 | Aura |
| 3 | Terry Bradshaw | Steelers | 14 | Great | Average | Elite | 81.7 | Aura |
| 4 | Patrick Mahomes | Chiefs | 9 | Elite | Elite | Elite | 81.6 | Aura |
| 5 | John Elway | Broncos | 16 | Good | Good | Elite | 73.9 | Sigma |
| 6 | Bart Starr | Packers | 16 | Good | Good | Elite | 71.2 | Sigma |
| 7 | Peyton Manning | Colts | 17 | Great | Great | Elite | 71.1 | Sigma |
| 8 | Ben Roethlisberger | Steelers | 18 | Great | Great | Elite | 70.4 | Sigma |
| 9 | Troy Aikman | Cowboys | 12 | Good | Good | Elite | 69.7 | Sigma |
| 10 | Roger Staubach | Cowboys | 11 | Elite | Good | Elite | 67.6 | Sigma |
| 11 | Otto Graham | Browns | 10 | Elite | Good | Elite | 62.6 | Sigma |
| 12 | Brett Favre | Packers | 20 | Good | Good | Elite | 61.2 | Sigma |
| 13 | Aaron Rodgers | Packers | 21 | Good | Elite | Great | 60.5 | Sigma |
| 14 | Eli Manning | Giants | 16 | Average | Good | Elite | 59.8 | Sigma |
| 15 | Johnny Unitas | Colts | 18 | Great | Good | Great | 59.1 | Sigma |
| 16 | Bob Griese | Dolphins | 14 | Great | Average | Elite | 58.4 | Sigma |
| 17 | Jim Plunkett | Raiders | 15 | Average | Subpar | Elite | 57.8 | Sigma |
| 18 | Russell Wilson | Seahawks | 14 | Great | Elite | Great | 57.7 | Sigma |
| 19 | Kurt Warner | Rams | 12 | Good | Good | Elite | 57.0 | Sigma |
| 20 | Drew Brees | Saints | 20 | Good | Great | Great | 56.3 | Sigma |
| 21 | Steve Young | 49ers | 15 | Great | Great | Great | 55.0 | Sigma |
| 22 | Len Dawson | Chiefs | 19 | Good | Good | Great | 54.9 | Sigma |
| 23 | Joe Theismann | Commanders | 12 | Good | Good | Great | 52.1 | Sigma |
| 24 | Fran Tarkenton | Vikings | 18 | Good | Good | Good | 51.4 | Sigma |
| 25 | Joe Flacco | Ravens | 18 | Good | Good | Great | 50.3 | Sigma |
| 26 | Jim Kelly | Bills | 11 | Great | Good | Great | 50.2 | Sigma |
| 27 | Phil Simms | Giants | 14 | Good | Good | Great | 50.1 | Sigma |
| 28 | Ken Stabler | Raiders | 15 | Great | Subpar | Great | 50.0 | Sigma |
| 29 | Jalen Hurts | Eagles | 6 | Great | Great | Great | 48.0 | Sigma |
| 30 | Donovan McNabb | Eagles | 13 | Good | Great | Good | 47.9 | Sigma |
| 31 | Dan Marino | Dolphins | 17 | Good | Great | Good | 47.1 | Sigma |
| 32 | Josh Allen | Bills | 8 | Great | Elite | Good | 43.3 | Slaps |
| 33 | Philip Rivers | Chargers | 17 | Good | Great | Average | 43.2 | Slaps |
| 34 | Matt Ryan | Falcons | 15 | Good | Great | Average | 43.1 | Slaps |
| 35 | Bobby Layne | Lions | 15 | Good | Subpar | Good | 43.0 | Slaps |
| 36 | Joe Burrow | Bengals | 6 | Good | Elite | Good | 42.9 | Slaps |
| 37 | Steve McNair | Titans | 13 | Good | Good | Good | 42.3 | Slaps |
| 38 | Earl Morrall | Dolphins | 21 | Good | Good | Good | 42.2 | Slaps |
| 39 | Danny White | Cowboys | 13 | Great | Good | Average | 42.0 | Slaps |
| 40 | Brad Johnson | Buccaneers | 15 | Good | Good | Good | 41.9 | Slaps |
| 41 | Joe Namath | Jets | 13 | Average | Subpar | Good | 41.8 | Slaps |
| 42 | Doug Williams | Commanders | 9 | Subpar | Good | Good | 41.7 | Slaps |
| 43 | Ron Jaworski | Eagles | 15 | Average | Good | Average | 41.6 | Slaps |
| 44 | Mark Brunell | Jaguars | 17 | Average | Good | Average | 41.5 | Slaps |
| 45 | Mark Rypien | Commanders | 11 | Good | Good | Great | 41.1 | Slaps |
| 46 | Jeff Hostetler | Giants | 12 | Good | Good | Good | 41.0 | Slaps |
| 47 | Boomer Esiason | Bengals | 14 | Average | Good | Average | 40.9 | Slaps |
| 48 | Dave Krieg | Seahawks | 19 | Good | Good | Subpar | 40.8 | Slaps |
| 49 | Jim McMahon | Bears | 15 | Great | Average | Good | 40.2 | Slaps |
| 50 | Jared Goff | Lions | 10 | Good | Great | Average | 40.1 | Slaps |
| 51 | Craig Morton | Cowboys | 18 | Good | Average | Good | 39.5 | Slaps |
| 52 | Ken Anderson | Bengals | 16 | Average | Good | Average | 39.4 | Slaps |
| 53 | Cam Newton | Panthers | 11 | Good | Good | Average | 38.7 | Slaps |
| 54 | Lamar Jackson | Ravens | 8 | Great | Elite | Average | 38.3 | Slaps |
| 55 | Tony Romo | Cowboys | 13 | Good | Great | Subpar | 38.2 | Slaps |
| 56 | Colin Kaepernick | 49ers | 6 | Average | Great | Good | 38.1 | Slaps |
| 57 | Nick Foles | Eagles | 11 | Average | Good | Good | 38.0 | Slaps |
| 58 | Matt Hasselbeck | Seahawks | 17 | Good | Good | Average | 37.4 | Slaps |
| 59 | John Brodie | 49ers | 17 | Average | Average | Average | 37.3 | Slaps |
| 60 | Dan Fouts | Chargers | 15 | Average | Average | Average | 36.6 | Slaps |