Buffalo Bills All-Time Quarterback Rankings
| Rank | Player | Rating | Overall |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sigma | ||
| 2 |
Josh Allen
Starter
#4 Active
|
Sigma | |
| 3 | Slaps | ||
| 4 | Delulu | ||
| 5 | Delulu | ||
| 6 | Delulu | ||
| 7 | Delulu | ||
| 8 |
Rob Johnson
|
Delulu | |
| 9 | NPC | ||
| 10 | NPC | ||
| 11 | NPC | ||
| 12 | NPC | ||
| 13 | NPC | ||
| 14 |
Ryan Fitzpatrick
|
NPC | |
| 15 | NPC | ||
| 16 | NPC | ||
| 17 | NPC | ||
| 18 | NPC | ||
| 19 | NPC | ||
| 20 | NPC | ||
| 21 | NPC | ||
| 22 | NPC | ||
| 23 |
Alex Van Pelt
|
Cooked | |
| 24 | NPC | ||
| 25 | Cooked | ||
| 26 | Cooked | ||
| 27 | Cooked | ||
| 28 | Cooked | ||
| 29 | Cooked | ||
| 30 |
Mitchell Trubisky
Roster
#69 Active
|
Cooked | |
| 31 | Cooked | ||
| 32 | Cooked | ||
| 33 | Cooked | ||
| 34 | Cooked | ||
| 35 | Cooked | ||
| 36 | Cooked | ||
| 37 |
Leo Hart
|
Cooked | |
| 38 | Cooked | ||
| 39 |
Nathan Peterman
|
Cooked | |
| 40 | Cooked |
Frequently Asked Questions About the Buffalo Bills
How does Josh Allen compare to Jim Kelly?
Josh Allen is the current franchise centerpiece in a more modern, QB-centric offense, while Jim Kelly remains the benchmark of past Bills success and long-term consistency in leading the team to multiple deep playoff runs.
Do the Bills support Josh Allen enough?
The Bills have built a receiver-tight end combo and retooled their line to keep the passing game explosive, and they continue tweaking protection and weapons to maximize Josh Allen’s impact in the postseason.
Will Bills draft another quarterback soon?
Buffalo is expected to prioritize other roster needs in early rounds and treat quarterback as a depth or developmental pick, relying on veteran stability around Josh Allen for the current playoff window.
What offensive system do the Bills run?
The Bills run an aggressive, pass-forward system tailored to Josh Allen’s arm and mobility, with play-calling designed to stress defenses vertically and use spread concepts while adjusting weekly for playoff matchups.
Who is the Buffalo Bills backup quarterback?
Behind starter Josh Allen, the Bills’ depth chart historically includes backups like Mitchell Trubisky and multiple developmental options, giving the organization flexibility if they need to adjust behind their starter.