Cleveland Browns All-Time Quarterback Rankings
| Rank | Player | Rating | Overall |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sigma | ||
| 2 | Chill | ||
| 3 | Chill | ||
| 4 | Delulu | ||
| 5 | Delulu | ||
| 6 | Delulu | ||
| 7 | Delulu | ||
| 8 | Delulu | ||
| 9 | Delulu | ||
| 10 | Delulu | ||
| 11 | Delulu | ||
| 12 |
Tommy O'Connell
|
Delulu | |
| 13 | NPC | ||
| 14 | NPC | ||
| 15 | NPC | ||
| 16 | NPC | ||
| 17 | NPC | ||
| 18 |
Shedeur Sanders
Starter
#37 Active
|
NPC | |
| 19 | NPC | ||
| 20 | NPC | ||
| 21 | NPC | ||
| 22 | NPC | ||
| 23 | NPC | ||
| 24 | NPC | ||
| 25 |
Deshaun Watson
Roster
#42 Active
|
NPC | |
| 26 | NPC | ||
| 27 | NPC | ||
| 28 |
George Ratterman
|
NPC | |
| 29 | NPC | ||
| 30 | NPC | ||
| 31 | NPC | ||
| 32 |
Josh McCown
|
NPC | |
| 33 | NPC | ||
| 34 |
Dillon Gabriel
Roster
#58 Active
|
Cooked | |
| 35 | Cooked | ||
| 36 | Cooked | ||
| 37 | Cooked | ||
| 38 | Cooked | ||
| 39 | Cooked | ||
| 40 | Cooked | ||
| 41 | Cooked | ||
| 42 | Cooked | ||
| 43 | Cooked | ||
| 44 | Cooked | ||
| 45 | Cooked | ||
| 46 | Cooked | ||
| 47 |
Jeff Christensen
|
Cooked | |
| 48 | Cooked | ||
| 49 | Cooked | ||
| 50 | Cooked | ||
| 51 | Cooked | ||
| 52 | Cooked | ||
| 53 |
Austin Davis
|
Cooked | |
| 54 | Cooked | ||
| 55 | Cooked | ||
| 56 | Cooked | ||
| 57 | Cooked | ||
| 58 | Cooked | ||
| 59 | Cooked | ||
| 60 | Cooked | ||
| 61 | Cooked | ||
| 62 | Cooked | ||
| 63 |
Ken Dorsey
|
Cooked | |
| 64 | Cooked | ||
| 65 | Cooked | ||
| 66 | Cooked | ||
| 67 | Cooked | ||
| 68 | Cooked | ||
| 69 | Cooked |
Frequently Asked Questions About the Cleveland Browns
How does Shedeur Sanders compare to Otto Graham?
Shedeur Sanders is the Browns’ current starter, while Otto Graham remains the franchise’s all-time benchmark at quarterback, so organizationally Sanders is viewed as the modern focal point trying to stabilize a spot once defined by Graham’s legacy.
How good is the Browns offensive support?
The Browns are expected to keep upgrading the offensive line and skill positions this offseason, aiming to create a more stable environment around the quarterback after cycling through options and changing head coaches.
Will the Browns draft another quarterback?
Cleveland is actively evaluating the 2026 quarterback class and could use its high first‑round pick and extra draft capital to add competition, though the front office has not ruled out sticking with internal options.
What offensive system will the Browns run?
With Kevin Stefanski fired and a new head coach search underway, the Browns’ offensive scheme and play‑calling philosophy are in flux and will be defined once the new staff is hired.
Who are the Browns backup quarterbacks?
Behind starter Shedeur Sanders, the Browns’ depth chart includes veteran Deshaun Watson and a large group of reserves such as Otto Graham, Bill Nelsen, Brian Sipe, Tim Couch, Kelly Holcomb, Johnny Manziel, Dorian Thompson-Robinson, and Bailey Zappe.