New York Giants logo
NFC East

New York Giants

4 Super Bowls 5 NFC Titles 1925 Founded
Starting QB
Jaxson Dart
19.2
#30 in the NFL

New York Giants All-Time Quarterback Rankings

43 Quarterbacks 3 Current
Rank Player Rating Season Fantasy Playoffs Overall Years
1 59.8 Average Good Elite Sigma 16
2 50.0 Good Good Great Sigma 14
3 43.6 Good Good Good Slaps 7
4 34.5 Great Subpar Average Chill 6
5 31.7 Average Average Average Delulu 5
6 29.6 Great Good Subpar Delulu 4
7 26.1 Subpar Good Average Delulu 1
8 26.1 Average Average Subpar Delulu 3
9 25.4 Good Average Subpar Delulu 1
10 21.1 Subpar Subpar Good Delulu 1
11 19.2 Subpar Great Non-Factor NPC 1
12 17.9 Subpar Good Non-Factor NPC 5
13 16.3 Average Subpar Non-Factor NPC 1
14 15.2 Subpar Subpar Non-Factor NPC 3
15 15.2 Subpar Subpar Non-Factor NPC 6
16 14.1 Subpar Subpar Non-Factor NPC 4
17 10.9 Subpar Good Non-Factor NPC 3
18
Kent Graham
10.8 Average Average Non-Factor NPC 5
19 10.6 Subpar Good Non-Factor NPC 2
20
Travis Tidwell
10.6 Good Subpar Non-Factor NPC 1
21 9.8 Subpar Average Non-Factor NPC 1
22 9.7 Subpar Average Non-Factor NPC 1
23 9.2 Subpar Average Non-Factor NPC 2
24 9.2 Subpar Subpar Non-Factor Cooked 4
25 8.8 Subpar Subpar Non-Factor Cooked 2
26 8.6 Subpar Subpar Non-Factor Cooked 7
27 8.6 Subpar Subpar Non-Factor Cooked 2
28 8.5 Subpar Subpar Non-Factor Cooked 3
29
Mike Busch
8.2 Non-Factor Average Non-Factor Cooked 1
30 8.2 Subpar Subpar Non-Factor Cooked 4
31 8.1 Non-Factor Average Non-Factor Cooked 3
32 7.9 Non-Factor Subpar Non-Factor Cooked 1
33 7.8 Non-Factor Average Non-Factor Cooked 1
34 7.5 Non-Factor Subpar Non-Factor Cooked 1
35 7.3 Non-Factor Subpar Non-Factor Cooked 5
36 7.1 Non-Factor Subpar Non-Factor Cooked 2
37 7.1 Non-Factor Subpar Non-Factor Cooked 1
38 6.8 Non-Factor Subpar Non-Factor Cooked 1
39 6.7 Subpar Non-Factor Non-Factor Cooked 3
40 6.4 Non-Factor Non-Factor Non-Factor Cooked 1
41 5.8 Non-Factor Non-Factor Non-Factor Cooked 1
42 5.8 Non-Factor Non-Factor Non-Factor Cooked 1
43 5.1 Non-Factor Non-Factor Non-Factor Cooked 1

Frequently Asked Questions About the New York Giants

How does Jaxson Dart compare to Eli Manning?

Jaxson Dart is the Giants’ current starting quarterback, while Eli Manning is the franchise legend whose long-term success and championships set the organizational standard Dart is now expected to uphold.

Do the Giants support Dart with enough weapons?

The Giants are committed to building around Jaxson Dart, with front-office focus on improving the offensive line and adding more reliable pass-catchers after an overall disappointing season on offense.

Will Giants draft another quarterback soon?

The Giants appear set to move forward with Jaxson Dart as starter, so draft and free-agency plans are more likely to target depth and future competition rather than replacing him immediately.

What offensive system will Dart play in?

With Brian Daboll out and the Giants linked to making a major coaching change, including possible interest in John Harbaugh, the offensive scheme and play-calling philosophy could shift significantly this offseason.

Who is backing up Jaxson Dart now?

Jameis Winston is expected to be Dart’s primary backup going into next season, with veterans like Russell Wilson likely departing and other backups on the roster for added depth and competition.