All-Time Browns QBs Ranked: Graham #1, Kosar #2

Shedeur Sanders

Starter 1 Year
1,400 Pass Yds
7 TDs
10 INTs
8 Total TDs
Shedeur's
HAIR
15.4
HeyTC AI Rating
#37 Active

Questions about Shedeur Sanders or the Browns?

Shedeur Sanders Today

HEYTC AI
Shedeur Sanders and the Cleveland Browns saw their disappointing 5-12 season end in a playoff elimination loss, capping a rookie year where the fifth-round surprise steal tallied just 1,400 passing yards, 7 TDs, and a dismal 20.6 QBR while taking over starts after Dillon Gabriel's concussion. In the Browns' final regular-season win over the Steelers, Sanders flashed potential with sharp anticipation and a game-winning drive against the Bengals, but he faltered in the postseason showdown, proving ineffective overall without key stats or highlights emerging. Ranked #37 in HeyTC AI Rankings, Sanders showed late progress but left the long-term QB question hanging, fueling offseason storylines around coaching changes post-Kevin Stefanski, potential trades like Denzel Ward what-ifs, and whether the Deion son can build on his seven starts. Fans eye free agency and the draft for weapons to ignite his arm next fall.

Shedeur Sanders Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
NPC
1 year with the Browns

Shedeur Sanders Contract & Salary

Status Rookie Contract

Shedeur Sanders 2025 Stats via ESPN

1,400 Pass Yards
7 Pass TDs
10 INTs
56.6% Comp %
15.4 HAIR
68.1 Passer Rtg
6.6 Y/A
8 Games
169 Rush Yards
1 Rush TDs

Should I Keep Shedeur Sanders?

HEYTC AI
DUMP 7/10 Confidence (High)

Shedeur Sanders flashed some upside but was one of the least-effective starters in 2025, posting poor efficiency and turnover issues on a Browns team that missed the playoffs. He is more of a speculative long-term stash than a locked-in fantasy starter, with significant risk tied to his performance and hold on the job.

Shedeur Sanders Fantasy Projections & Matchup Analysis
QB24-28 range Dynasty Rank
23 Age
3-5 years (if development hits) Elite Years Left
Medium Trade Value
Career Trajectory: Rising

Only worth keeping if his cost is very cheap (late-round or end-of-bench keeper) or in deep superflex/2QB formats; do not pay a premium pick or starter-level keeper slot for him after a season with 7 TD and 10 INT in limited action. In standard 1QB leagues, he is a fringe keeper and often better treated as a waiver-wire or trade chip than a protected asset.

Team Situation

Cleveland finished outside the top of the draft order and out of the playoffs but appears committed to building around Sanders while likely adding veteran competition rather than spending a premium pick on a new quarterback. Coaching and scheme could change after a disappointing year, adding some risk to his situation but also the possibility of a more QB-friendly environment.

Long-term Factors
  • Showed just enough promise in his late-season starts (1,400 yards, 7 TD, 10 INT) to remain in the mix for the 2026 starting job but not enough to be secure.
  • Organizational investment and lack of an obvious path to a blue-chip rookie QB give him a reasonable chance to keep or regain the job, even if the team brings in a veteran competitor.
  • Accuracy, pocket timing, and turnover problems from 2025 keep his range of outcomes wide, making him more of a boom-bust long-range prospect than a safe dynasty QB anchor.

Shedeur Sanders Career Timeline

HEYTC AI
2026 1

Faces veteran competition for Browns QB1 role

Ahead of the 2026 season, reports indicated the Browns were considering adding a veteran quarterback such as Mac Jones to compete with Sanders, reflecting the team’s view that while Sanders had shown promise, he had not fully secured the long-term starting role.

2025 5

Completes rookie season as Browns starter

Sanders finished his rookie year having started the final seven games for Cleveland, posting approximately 1,353–1,400 passing yards with seven touchdowns and nine to ten interceptions, going 3–4 as a starter and showing enough flashes to remain in the conversation for the 2026 starting job.

Records best rookie performance vs. Titans

In Week 14 of his rookie season against the Tennessee Titans, Sanders delivered his most productive outing, throwing for 364 yards, three touchdowns, and one interception in a narrow loss in what became known locally as the infamous Kevin Stefanski two-point conversion game.

Earns Browns starting QB job late in rookie season

After Joe Flacco was traded and Dillon Gabriel suffered a concussion, Sanders made his first career start in Week 12, a 24–10 win over the Las Vegas Raiders, and remained the Browns’ starter for the final seven games of the 2025 season.

Starts season buried on Browns depth chart

Sanders opened his rookie year near the bottom of the Browns quarterback depth chart in training camp behind veteran Joe Flacco and fellow rookie Dillon Gabriel, facing skepticism and limited early practice reps before injuries and a trade reshaped the depth chart.

Drafted by Cleveland Browns in fifth round

Shedeur Sanders was selected by the Cleveland Browns in the fifth round of the 2025 NFL Draft as the 144th overall pick, entering the league amid expectations that he had been drafted later than many analysts had projected for his talent level.

1 years in the NFL

Frequently Asked Questions About Shedeur Sanders

Is Shedeur Sanders playing this week for the Cleveland Browns?

Yes, Shedeur Sanders is currently expected to be available as the Cleveland Browns’ starting quarterback, with no new injury setbacks reported after he finished his rookie season healthy. Deshaun Watson missed the entire 2025 season with an Achilles injury and remains in recovery, which has kept Sanders in the primary role.

How did Shedeur Sanders play in his most recent game for the Browns?

In his most recent game, a Week 17 upset win over the Pittsburgh Steelers, Shedeur Sanders completed 17 of 23 passes for 186 yards with 1 touchdown and 2 interceptions. He also led the first game‑winning drive of his NFL career in that 13–6 victory, snapping a four‑game Browns losing streak.

Will Shedeur Sanders be traded or replaced as the Browns’ starting quarterback?

Current reporting indicates the Browns are likely to head into the upcoming season with Shedeur Sanders taking snaps as their primary quarterback rather than trading him or immediately going back to Deshaun Watson. Team decision‑makers are instead focused on upgrading the supporting cast (offensive line and receivers) around Sanders, suggesting organizational commitment rather than trade talks.

Is Shedeur Sanders a top 10 quarterback right now?

No, Shedeur Sanders is not considered a top‑10 quarterback at this time; he currently ranks <strong>No. 38</strong> on HeyTC's Daily AI Quarterback Rankings with an NPC overall rating of <strong>14.11 (tier)</strong>. That placement reflects a rough but developmental rookie season in which his performance has been viewed as promising but clearly outside the league’s elite.

Who do Shedeur Sanders and the Browns play next, and what is the outlook for that matchup?

Reports about Cleveland’s offseason focus. such as targeting upgrades like center Tyler Linderbaum and a true No. 1 receiver. indicate that Sanders’ next meaningful action will come in the upcoming season rather than an imminent game this week. With the Browns finishing 5–12 and missing the playoffs, the next matchup on the calendar is their 2026 regular‑season opener, where Sanders is currently projected to start behind an improved supporting cast.

What is the biggest current storyline around Shedeur Sanders with the Browns?

The major storyline is the internal debate over whether Shedeur Sanders has done enough to firmly claim the Browns’ long‑term QB1 job over Deshaun Watson after a rocky but growth‑filled rookie year. Cleveland just fired head coach Kevin Stefanski after a 5–12 season, and new coaching plus potential offensive reinforcements have made Sanders’ development and status as presumptive 2026 starter one of the franchise’s central questions.