All-Time Broncos QBs Ranked: Elway #1, Manning #2

Jarrett Stidham

#8 · Denver Broncos
Retired 3 Years In The NFL
🏆 SEC Newcomer of the Year (2017)
Jarrett's
HAIR
8.7
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Jarrett Stidham or the Broncos?

Jarrett Stidham Legacy

HEYTC AI
Jarrett Stidham, the lanky Kentucky gunslinger who ditched Baylor for Auburn glory, embodies the eternal NFL backup grind—poised, unflappable, always one snap from chaos. Fourth-round pick in '19, he's bounced from Belichick's Pats lab to Raiders relief (career-high 656 yards in '22 starts) and now Broncos bench warmer, flashing SEC Newcomer shine without the spotlight. What defines him? That cool-headed poise in spot duty, like '23 Denver cameos amid Russell Wilson drama, proving he's the ultimate insurance policy—reliable arm, zero quit, forever the guy teams love but rarely unleash. Legacy: journeyman prep for whatever's next.

Jarrett Stidham Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
2 years with the Broncos

Jarrett Stidham Career Stats via Wikipedia

1,422 Pass Yards
8 Touchdowns
8 INTs
59.4% Comp %
8.7 HAIR
1-3 Record

Frequently Asked Questions About Jarrett Stidham

How does Bo Nix compare to Jarrett Stidham?

Bo Nix has leapfrogged Jarrett Stidham as the Broncos' undisputed starter, turning Stidham into the reliable backup holding the clipboard like a seasoned understudy. Nix's rookie poise echoes a young Drew Brees in command, while Stidham's career—1,422 yards, 8 TDs over spot starts—keeps him as Payton's trusted insurance, not the lead actor.

Is Jarrett Stidham in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Jarrett Stidham isn't in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no bronze bust in Canton waiting for him. With just 1,422 career passing yards and 8 TDs across 16 games as a journeyman backup, he's lightyears from the immortals; think more reliable clipboard holder than ring-of-fame material.

What is Jarrett Stidham doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Jarrett Stidham's locked in as the Broncos' top backup on that two-year, $12 million deal he signed in March 2025, ready to spell Bo Nix if needed. No broadcasting gigs or charity headlines yet—just Sean Payton's familiar system, a few quiet snaps in '24, and that veteran steadiness behind Denver's rising star.

How would Jarrett Stidham perform in today's NFL?

Stidham's quick release and 89.2 passer rating in his five '22 starts would fit snugly in today's pass-happy NFL, where rules shield QBs like never before. Those 656 yards and 4 TDs showed pocket savvy, but he'd thrive as a bridge guy, not a star—modern defenses still expose his arm talent limits.

How does Jarrett Stidham compare to John Elway?

Comparing Jarrett Stidham's 8.68-ish rating flashes to John Elway's sky-high 71.78 is like pitting a reliable rental car against a Ferrari—both Broncos QBs, sure, but Elway engineered miracles while Stidham's 1,422 yards and 8 TDs scream career backup, not franchise savior.