EJ Manuel

Josh Allen towers over EJ Manuel like a snowplow over a tricycle—Allen's got 30,000-plus yards and MVP buzz while EJ's stuck at 3,767 in a Bills tenure defined by knee woes and backup gigs. Manuel was the shiny first-round hope in 2013; Allen's the cannon-armed wrecking ball delivering playoffs after decades of drought.

Nah, EJ Manuel's not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no bust in Canton for the guy who flickered as Buffalo's 2013 first-rounder before injuries and journeyman stints with Oakland and KC dimmed the lights. His 20 TDs and 3,767 yards whisper "what if," not "enshrined."

Since hanging up the cleats in 2019, EJ Manuel's carved a post-football lane as a college football analyst on the ACC Network, blending FSU roots with sharp breakdowns. That Fantex stock deal from 2014? Still a quirky footnote in his pivot to media and maybe quiet charity gigs—no Chiefs comeback here.

EJ's dual-threat zip from Florida State might pop more under today's pass-happy rules—no more mugging mobile QBs—but his 58% completion and injury fragility scream backup in this Mahomes era. Imagine him dodging sacks like 2013, but with RPOs? Fun flashes, not franchise savior.

Jim Kelly's a Bills pantheon god with 35,467 yards and that 49.97% winning clip; EJ Manuel's 16.47% mark over 30 games feels like a pop warner warm-up by comparison. Both franchise first-rounders, but Kelly owned the '90s—Manuel just dodged international Ls from London to Mexico City.