All-Time Colts QBs Ranked: Manning #1, Unitas #2

Andrew Luck

Retired 6 Years In The NFL
🏆 NFL Comeback Player of the Year (2018)
Andrew's
HAIR
35.9
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Andrew Luck or the Colts?

Andrew Luck Legacy

HEYTC AI
Andrew Luck was the gunslinger savant who stepped into Peyton Manning's shadow as the No. 1 pick and immediately lit Indy ablaze, shattering rookie records while dragging a 2-14 corpse to 11 wins. What made him special? That cannon arm fused with a magician's pocket presence, authoring seven game-winning drives as a newbie, torching the Legion of Boom, and outdueling Peyton for the TD crown—before injuries turned promise into a gut-wrenching exit at 29. Now thriving as Stanford's GM, book-club curator, and high school coach, Luck's legacy whispers "what if," but roars resilience: the decade's yardage king per game, proving brilliance needs no ring to endure.

Andrew Luck Rating Breakdown

Season
Good
Fantasy
Great
Playoffs
Average
Overall
Chill
6 years with the Colts

Andrew Luck Career Stats via Wikipedia

23,671 Pass Yards
171 Touchdowns
83 INTs
60.8% Comp %
35.9 HAIR
53-33 Record

Andrew Luck Career Timeline

HEYTC AI
2019 1

Abrupt Retirement

Luck abruptly retired from the NFL at age 29 after a preseason game, following a career plagued by injuries with the Colts.

2016 1

Leads Win Over Bears

Luck guided the Colts to a 29-23 victory over the Chicago Bears, with players reacting positively on social media.

2013 1

Playoff Comeback vs. Chiefs

In his second playoff game, Luck threw for 443 yards and five total touchdowns, leading the Colts to a dramatic comeback win against the Kansas City Chiefs.

2012 2

Rookie Season Milestone

As a rookie, Luck recorded 339 completions, ranking among the highest for rookie quarterbacks in NFL history.

Drafted by Colts

Andrew Luck was the first overall pick in the 2012 NFL Draft by the Indianapolis Colts.

6 years in the NFL

Frequently Asked Questions About Andrew Luck

How does Daniel Jones compare to Andrew Luck?

Daniel Jones stepping in as Colts starter? That's like swapping a Ferrari for a reliable sedan—Luck's 23,671 yards and 171 TDs over seven seasons dwarf Jones's output, with that cannon arm and pocket poise that screamed superstar before injuries hit. Jones scrambles well, but Luck's pre-shoulder apocalypse vision would've shredded this pass-happy era; legacy-wise, Luck's the one fans still pine for in Indy.[62 words]

Is Andrew Luck in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Andrew Luck's not in Canton yet—retired at 29 after that brutal injury saga, so no bust on the horizon despite those 171 TDs and Comeback Player fireworks in '18. Hall voters love longevity, and his seven-year flash, brilliant as it was, got cut short like a bad draft pick. Give it a decade; the whispers might grow if Stanford's turnaround sticks.[58 words]

What is Andrew Luck doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Luck's running Stanford football as GM, fresh off a 4-8 '25 where he raised $100 million and snagged Tavita Pritchard as head coach after 30 interviews—classic Luck, all-in on the rebuild. Misses the game but not QB hits, now wielding NIL savvy and portal magic to chase that powerhouse vibe he owned as a Cardinal legend.[59 words]

How would Andrew Luck perform in today's NFL?

Luck in today's NFL? He'd feast—those zip lasers and football IQ would've torched under softer roughing rules, no doubt top-5 with quick releases and that escapability. Modern offenses match his wheelhouse; imagine him slinging to AR-15 types without the old-school pounding that wrecked his shoulder. Injuries aside, he'd adapt like he did post-'16 surgery, racking up MVP chatter.[56 words]

How does Andrew Luck compare to Peyton Manning?

Luck vs. Peyton? Both Colts saviors, but Manning's 55.59 rating laps Luck's 35.9—Peyton's surgical precision and records (hello, five MVPs) tower, while Luck battled chaos with grit, nearly dragging '13 and '14 squads to playoffs. Like handing Peyton a Ferrari and Luck a jalopy; both icons, but Peyton's the GOAT benchmark Luck chased in those blue jerseys.[57 words]