All-Time Colts QBs Ranked: Manning #1, Unitas #2

Scott Tolzien

Indianapolis Colts
Retired 4 Years In The NFL
🏆 Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award (2010)
Scott's
HAIR
5.2
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Scott Tolzien or the Colts?

Scott Tolzien Legacy

HEYTC AI
Scott Tolzien, the Wisconsin gunslinger who pocketed the Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award in 2010, was the ultimate football lifer—undrafted, unflappable, and always ready when the stars aligned (or got concussed). Picture this Badger hero stepping in for Aaron Rodgers in Lambeau, slinging 339 yards against the Giants in his first full start, or that cheeky spin move on a TD scamper versus the Vikings. Backup gigs with the Packers and Colts defined his brief NFL whirl, but Tolzien's real legacy shines now as the New Orleans Saints' quarterbacks coach, molding the next wave with that same Midwestern grit and pocket poise that made him special.

Scott Tolzien Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
2 years with the Colts

Scott Tolzien Career Stats via Wikipedia

1,065 Pass Yards
2 Touchdowns
9 INTs
60.3% Comp %
5.2 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Scott Tolzien

How does Daniel Jones compare to Scott Tolzien?

Daniel Jones towers over Scott Tolzien like a skyscraper next to a shed—Jones is locking down the Colts starting gig with real arm talent and poise, while Tolzien's "legacy" is that grim 5.2 passer rating across 1,065 yards, 2 TDs, and a Thanksgiving nightmare start versus Pittsburgh. Backup city forever.

Is Scott Tolzien in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Scott Tolzien's not chilling in Canton with the busts—no Hall of Fame nod for the journeyman who slung it for Green Bay and Indy without ever sniffing elite status. His 1,065 career yards and 2 TDs? Solid clipboard warmer, but Pro Football immortality's for gunslingers, not spot starters.

What is Scott Tolzien doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Tolzien's molding minds as the Saints' QB coach, fresh off two years tutoring Dak Prescott in Dallas and a Wisconsin analyst stint post-retirement. He's breaking down tape with Tyler Shough on local radio, eyes maybe on coordinator gigs—Commanders have him on the radar. Coaching suits his cerebral game.

How would Scott Tolzien perform in today's NFL?

Tolzien's quick release and smarts might snag a few more yards in today's pass-happy NFL with its bubble screens and RPOs, but that 62% completion and pick-prone arm from his Indy days scream eternal backup. Modern rules favor guns; he'd be a poor man's Case Keenum, holding clipboards in shotgun spreads.

How does Scott Tolzien compare to Peyton Manning?

Peyton Manning's 55.59 rating with the Colts is galactic compared to Tolzien's feeble 5.2—think Zeus versus a mortal who wandered onto the field. Both wore the horseshoe, but Peyton built dynasties; Scott was the emergency brake when Luck went down, all fumes and no fireworks.