Kyle Orton

Caleb Williams operates in a completely different stratosphere—he's a generational talent with MVP-caliber arm talent and mobility that Orton never possessed. Where Orton threw 101 TDs over 12 seasons with a 71.1 rating in Chicago, Williams is built to dominate the modern pass-happy NFL. Orton was a competent game-manager; Williams is a franchise cornerstone.

No, Kyle Orton never made Canton and won't—his 18,037 career yards and 101 TDs don't crack the Hall's threshold for QB consideration. He was a solid, durable backup-turned-starter who did his job without distinction. There's no Hall case here, and Orton himself would probably tell you that.

The search results don't reveal Orton's current 2026 activities, so I can't tell you what he's doing now—whether that's broadcasting, business ventures, or staying out of the spotlight entirely. His playing days ended in 2014, but his post-football path isn't documented in available sources.

Orton's 71.1 rating with the Bears would likely improve under today's rules—softer coverage, more wide-open spacing, and penalty-happy officiating favor rhythm passers. That said, his arm talent was never elite, and he'd still be a game-manager type. He'd probably be a competent backup in 2026, maybe a low-end starter on a defense-first team.

McMahon crushes Orton in the legacy department—his 45.04 rating and Super Bowl XX championship define Bears quarterback history. Orton was the forgettable interim guy who kept the seat warm; McMahon was the swashbuckling gunslinger who won it all. Not even close.