All-Time Buffalo Bills QB Rankings: Kelly #1, Allen #2

Frank Reich

Retired 13 Years In The NFL
Frank's
HAIR
7.4
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Frank Reich or the Bills?

Frank Reich Legacy

HEYTC AI
Frank Reich, the ultimate comeback kid, etched his name in gridiron immortality with that jaw-dropping 32-point rally against the Houston Oilers in the 1993 wild-card game—still the NFL's biggest playoff turnaround, subbing for Jim Kelly to torch Houston for 289 yards and four TDs in a 41-38 OT thriller. A reliable Bills backup across four straight Super Bowls, he later morphed into one of football's sharpest offensive minds, calling the Philly Special in Super Bowl LII en route to a ring as Eagles OC, then resurrecting Andrew Luck's Colts for a stunning 10-6 turnaround. Now a senior advisor at Stanford, Reich's career proves grit and ingenuity trump flash every time.

Frank Reich Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
9 years with the Bills

Frank Reich Career Stats via Wikipedia

6,075 Pass Yards
40 Touchdowns
36 INTs
0.0% Comp %
7.4 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Frank Reich

How does Josh Allen compare to Frank Reich?

Frank Reich's the ultimate Bills backup legend, etching his name with that insane 32-point playoff rally against Houston in '93, while Josh Allen's out there authoring a gunslinger epic week in, week out as the franchise torchbearer. Reich's legacy is that one eternal miracle; Allen's stacking volumes toward Canton. Polar opposites, both pure Buffalo poetry.

Is Frank Reich in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Frank Reich's not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no gold jacket in Canton for the comeback king. His 6,075 yards and 40 TDs over 14 seasons were solid relief work behind Jim Kelly, but starters get the busts. That '93 Oilers miracle keeps his highlight reel glowing forever, Hall or no.

What is Frank Reich doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Frank Reich's chilling post-firing from Carolina in '23—no head gig, no booth chatter, just leveraging that coaching tree goldmine. Nick Sirianni's Eagles won it all in '24 under his influence, and he's likely knee-deep in family, faith stuff, or advising quietly. Guy's earned the victory lap.

How would Frank Reich perform in today's NFL?

Reich would feast in today's pass-happy NFL—think quicker drops, no more bruising hits, rules shielding QBs like him. His '93 playoff poise (going 4-for-5 for 88 yards in that comeback drive) translates to a reliable bridge guy, maybe carving 250 yards a start. Mobility? Nah, but arm and smarts age like fine wine.

How does Frank Reich compare to Jim Kelly?

Jim Kelly owned Buffalo as the Hall-bound gunslinger with a 49.97 career rating; Reich, his trusty understudy, scraped an 8.81 rating across spot starts and that eternal Oilers epic. Kelly was the Ferrari, Reich the tow truck that once won the race—both Bills lifers, but one's the statue, other's the footnote with flair.