All-Time Buffalo Bills QB Rankings: Kelly #1, Allen #2

Brian McClure

Retired 1 Year In The NFL
🏆 Sammy Baugh Trophy (1985)
Brian's
HAIR
7.7
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Brian McClure or the Bills?

Brian McClure Legacy

HEYTC AI
Brian McClure, the cannon-armed kid from Rootstown, Ohio, who bled orange and brown for Bowling Green, owned the Mid-American Conference like few ever have—three-time Offensive Player of the Year, Sammy Baugh Trophy winner, Heisman dark horse, and the architect of a 32-9 run capped by national rankings and MAC titles. A 12th-round Bills pick in '86, he etched his NFL footnote in one glorious '87 start: 20-of-38 for 181 yards, holding the single-game records for any one-and-done QB, and—get this—the only Buffalo signal-caller to win every contest he started. Pinpoint leader, unbreakable competitor, forever Falcon legend.

Brian McClure Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
1 year with the Bills

Brian McClure Career Stats via Wikipedia

0 Pass Yards
0 Touchdowns
3 INTs
0.0% Comp %
7.7 HAIR
32-10 Record

Frequently Asked Questions About Brian McClure

How does Josh Allen compare to Brian McClure?

Josh Allen's a cannon-armed freight train, dropping 4,000-yard seasons like it's nothing, while Brian McClure's one-game Bills miracle—20-for-38, 181 yards, perfect 1-0 record—feels like a gritty footnote from '86. Allen's chasing rings in the big leagues; McClure owns the quirky stat of most yards by a one-game wonder, no TDs needed to steal the show.

Is Brian McClure in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, Brian McClure's not in Canton—his NFL stay was a single '86 Bills cameo with 181 yards and a win, not Hall territory. But dig deeper: guy's a Bowling Green legend, 10,280 college yards, 32-9 record, three-time MAC star. Perfect 1-0 in Buffalo? That's his eternal mic drop over any bust.

What is Brian McClure doing now in 2026?

In 2025, McClure's still repping his Bowling Green roots hard, spotlighted in their Decades Celebration for that '85 orange-and-brown fire—10,280 yards, Heisman buzz, unbreakable team loyalty. No fresh 2026 headlines on biz or broadcasts, but he's the eternal Falcon bleeding school spirit, probably grilling tales at alumni gigs.

How would Brian McClure perform in today's NFL?

McClure's laser arm and poise from 10,280 college yards would feast under today's pass-happy rules—no more '80s thumpers sacking him silly. That '86 Bills relief stint (52% comp, 32.9 rating) was raw, but modern protections? He'd sling 300-yarders weekly, channeling his 32-9 Falcon grit into a solid backup carving starter snaps.

How does Brian McClure compare to Jim Kelly?

Jim Kelly's 49.97 passer rating lit up Buffalo for a decade; McClure's 7.72 came in one chaotic '86 relief outing—20-for-38, 181 yards, zero picks but no scores. Both franchise trigger-men, yet Kelly built empires while McClure's the ultimate what-if: perfect 1-0 starter, holding NFL one-game records like a charming glitch in the matrix.