All-Time Buffalo Bills QB Rankings: Kelly #1, Allen #2

Gary Marangi

Retired 3 Years In The NFL
Gary's
HAIR
7.3
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Gary Marangi or the Bills?

Gary Marangi Legacy

HEYTC AI
Gary Marangi, the Rockville Centre kid who lit up Boston College with a gunslinger’s arm, stepped into the NFL spotlight as Buffalo’s third-round hope in ’74, firing his first-ever pass—a touchdown dart to J.D. Hill against Miami. Thrust into the Bills’ starting role in ’76 when Joe Ferguson went down, Marangi gutted through shoulder woes and a brutal 35.3% completion clip, embodying the grit of a franchise forever chasing daylight. No fairy tale, but a blue-collar tale of a backup who answered the bell, leaving Western New York fans with memories of raw potential amid the Rich Stadium roar.

Gary Marangi Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
3 years with the Bills

Gary Marangi Career Stats via Wikipedia

1,373 Pass Yards
12 Touchdowns
21 INTs
0.0% Comp %
7.3 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Gary Marangi

How does Josh Allen compare to Gary Marangi?

Josh Allen and Gary Marangi occupy different universes. Allen's a generational talent with MVP hardware and playoff success; Marangi threw 12 TDs against 21 INTs across three Bills seasons in the mid-70s. Allen's completing 63% of passes; Marangi's worst season hit 35.3%. The gap between them isn't just era—it's talent level, durability, and opportunity.

Is Gary Marangi in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

No, Gary Marangi is not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. His three-year Buffalo tenure was marked by shoulder injuries and brutal statistics—that 30.8 passer rating in 1976 doesn't exactly scream Canton credentials. He's a footnote in Bills history, not a bust.

What is Gary Marangi doing now in 2026?

The search results don't contain information about Gary Marangi's current activities in 2026. Without recent data on his business ventures, broadcasting work, or charitable involvement, I can't speak to what he's doing now. If you're looking for specifics, you'd need more recent sources.

How would Gary Marangi perform in today's NFL?

Modern passing rules would help Marangi's volume stats but wouldn't fix his fundamental issues. Today's softer defenses and emphasis on quick releases play to his strengths, yet his 36.7% career completion rate and shoulder problems would still plague him. He'd throw more TDs but also more INTs—a volume play that doesn't solve the accuracy problem.

How does Gary Marangi compare to Jim Kelly?

Jim Kelly destroyed Marangi in every meaningful way. Kelly's 49.97 rating versus Marangi's 36.1 tells the story—one's a Hall of Famer, the other couldn't stay healthy enough to be a backup. Kelly won Super Bowls; Marangi won games against his own decision-making.