All-Time Buffalo Bills QB Rankings: Kelly #1, Allen #2

Kay Stephenson

Retired 1 Year In The NFL
🏆 World Bowl champion (II)
Kay's
HAIR
6.9
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Kay Stephenson or the Bills?

Kay Stephenson Legacy

HEYTC AI
Kay Stephenson is a former NFL quarterback. who played for the San Diego Chargers, Buffalo Bills, Jacksonville Sharks (WFL), Los Angeles Rams, Sacramento Surge, Sacramento Gold Miners, San Antonio Texans, Arkansas Razorbacks, Edmonton Eskimos.

Kay Stephenson Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
1 year with the Bills

Kay Stephenson Career Stats

Statistics are being loaded. Check back soon.

Frequently Asked Questions About Kay Stephenson

How does Josh Allen compare to Kay Stephenson?

Kay Stephenson's a footnote to Josh Allen's epic saga—think scrappy AFL journeyman with 1,296 career yards versus Allen's cannon arm rewriting Bills lore weekly. Kay backed up legends like Kemp in leather-helmet days; Josh is the dual-threat freight train building a dynasty. Different eras, same blue-collar Bills blood, but Allen's the supernova.

Is Kay Stephenson in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, Kay Stephenson's not in Canton—his QB stats were gritty filler, not gold-jacket stuff, and his head coaching go 10-26 with the Bills. Solid AFL backup and World Bowl champ in Europe, but Hall voters skipped the Florida Gator who slung it old-school without the spotlight shine.

What is Kay Stephenson doing now in 2026?

As of 2026, Kay Stephenson's off the grid—no headlines on broadcasting gigs, business ventures, or charity drives. The old Bills QB/coach, last spotted coaching in the '90s WLAF glory, likely chilling in retirement mode, maybe mentoring grandkids or hitting Florida links, far from NFL radars.

How would Kay Stephenson perform in today's NFL?

Kay's quick-release AFL arm might carve a backup niche today—modern rules ban the old bump-and-run, letting pocket passers thrive like never before. But his 43% completion and 20 picks in 255 tries scream third-stringer behind Mahomes types; no mobile magic to wow in this RPO era.

How does Kay Stephenson compare to Jim Kelly?

Kay Stephenson's 6.93 passer rating looks prehistoric next to Jim Kelly's 49.97 fireworks—both Bills franchise gunslingers, but Kelly torched AFC East defenses while Kay mopped up behind Kemp with Elway-level picks. Kay's the warm-up act; Kelly headlined the '90s party.