All-Time Bears QBs Ranked: McMahon #1, Wade #2

Nathan Peterman

Chicago Bears
Retired 4 Years In The NFL
🏆 | statseason = 2024
Nathan's
HAIR
6.7
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Nathan Peterman or the Bears?

Nathan Peterman Legacy

HEYTC AI
Nathan Peterman, the lanky Florida gunslinger who lit up Pitt with a legendary five-TD masterpiece against undefeated Clemson—their only loss en route to a title—arrived in the NFL as Buffalo's fifth-round flier in 2017, only to etch his name in infamy with five picks in his debut half, a 0.0 rating stinker, and a league-record 11 INTs on under 100 throws. From Bills to Raiders, Bears, Saints, and Falcons, he bounced as the ultimate journeyman punchline, "historically bad" per USA Today, yet his college magic hinted at what might've been in a kinder universe. In QB lore, he's the ultimate what-if cautionary tale.

Nathan Peterman Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
2 years with the Bears

Nathan Peterman Career Stats via Wikipedia

712 Pass Yards
4 Touchdowns
13 INTs
53.1% Comp %
6.7 HAIR
1-4 Record

Frequently Asked Questions About Nathan Peterman

How does Caleb Williams compare to Nathan Peterman?

Caleb Williams, the Bears' shiny new starter, towers over Nathan Peterman like a Ferrari next to a rusted Pinto—Williams slinging dimes while Peterman's career ledger reads 712 yards, 4 TDs, and a gruesome 13 picks across stints in Buffalo, Vegas, and Chicago. Peterman's the punchline benchmark for busts; Caleb's out to rewrite Bears QB history, not echo it.

Is Nathan Peterman in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nathan Peterman's not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no plaque in Canton for the guy who tied an NFL record with five picks in his debut start against the Chargers. His 39.4 passer rating and "historically bad" Buffalo runs keep him firmly off any enshrinement radar, more trivia than legend.

What is Nathan Peterman doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Nathan Peterman's riding the bench on Atlanta's practice squad as emergency QB depth, signed after preseason cuts from Vegas and a couple spot Bears gigs in '22-'23. No broadcasting gigs or charity headlines yet—just the grind of a 30-something vet chasing that elusive roster spot like a gambler on a cold streak.

How would Nathan Peterman perform in today's NFL?

Peterman's arm talent and mobility might snag a few chunk plays under today's pass-happy rules—no more 1970s thumpers—but his decision-making screams disaster, with 13 INTs on 712 yards. He'd feast on garbage time, sure, but starters like Caleb Williams expose why he's practice squad fodder, not a 2026 savior.

How does Nathan Peterman compare to Jim McMahon?

Comparing Peterman's Bears blur (6.74 rating on 25-for-14 with a pick) to Jim McMahon's gritty '85 magic (45.04 rating, Super Bowl sparkplug) is like pitting a pop gun against a howitzer—both wore the orange, but McMahon delivered Fog Bowl fire while Peterman's cameos were forgettable fumbles in the shadows.