All-Time Lions QBs Ranked: Layne #1, Goff #2

Scott Mitchell

Detroit Lions
Retired 11 Years In The NFL
Scott's
HAIR
26.8
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Scott Mitchell or the Lions?

Scott Mitchell Legacy

HEYTC AI
Scott Mitchell, the cannon-armed gunslinger from Springville, Utah, who could sling it like few others, etched his name in Lions lore with that monster 1995 season—4,338 yards, 32 TDs, franchise marks that screamed superstar in a silver-and-Honolulu blue helmet. He dragged Detroit to playoffs in '95 and '97, rare sunshine in the Barry Sanders era, before bouncing to Baltimore and Cincy. Back home, he coached Springville to near-glory, then shocked the world shedding 120 pounds on The Biggest Loser, rediscovering the Ute legend who snapped BYU's nine-game streak. Mitchell's tale? Pure grit, from gridiron guns to life’s comeback king.

Scott Mitchell Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Good
Playoffs
Subpar
Overall
Delulu
5 years with the Lions

Scott Mitchell Career Stats

Statistics are being loaded. Check back soon.

Frequently Asked Questions About Scott Mitchell

How does Jared Goff compare to Scott Mitchell?

Scott Mitchell's Lions run peaked with a 4,338-yard, 32-TD explosion in '95, dragging Detroit to the playoffs, but his 75.3 career rating and injury hiccups left him as a what-if guy. Jared Goff? He's crafting a steadier saga at 67% completion, threading needles in this no-hit paradise—Mitchell's gunslinger arm might dazzle, yet Goff's poise owns Ford Field now.

Is Scott Mitchell in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Scott Mitchell's not in Canton—his '95 Lions explosion set passing marks Stafford later torched, but a 75.3 rating and playoff flameouts like that 58-37 dumpster fire keep him off the gold jacket list. Solid journeyman, not bronze-bust material; think Barry Sanders' backup quarterback, forever in the shadow.

What is Scott Mitchell doing now in 2026?

By 2026, Mitchell's deep into his Utah software empire after coaching Springville High to near-glory and a 'Biggest Loser' TV glow-up. No broadcasting gigs or charity headlines popping lately—he's the quiet ex-QB building apps, not calling games, proving some gridiron gunslingers pivot harder than a blindside blitz.

How would Scott Mitchell perform in today's NFL?

Mitchell's cannon arm and '95 deep-ball magic—4,338 yards, 32 TDs—would feast in today's pass-happy rules with no defenders teeing off like '90s thugs. His 59% completion might climb to Goff-ish levels with better protection, though that pick-six itch could haunt him against zone blitzes. Retro rocket in a spread world.

How does Scott Mitchell compare to Bobby Layne?

Bobby Layne owned the Lions' soul with a 38.72 rating, chain-smoking wins in the gritty '50s, while Mitchell's 26.76 mark screamed '90s boom-or-bust—think 32 TDs in '95 versus Layne's field-general grit. Both franchise torchbearers, but Layne's the whiskey-soaked legend; Mitchell, the fleeting fireworks show.