All-Time Jets QBs Ranked: Namath #1, Pennington #2

Joe Namath

Retired 13 Years In The NFL
🏆 Super Bowl champion (III)
Joe's
HAIR
40.8
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Joe Namath or the Jets?

Joe Namath Legacy

HEYTC AI
Broadway Joe was less a quarterback than a cultural force—a swagger-slinging gunslinger who made the AFL matter before it merged into irrelevance. He arrived in New York as a $427,000 celebrity and never stopped acting like one, posing in pantyhose and guaranteeing Super Bowl victories like a man who'd already seen the script. That 1969 guarantee against Baltimore wasn't arrogance; it was prophecy, and when the Jets won 16-7, Namath didn't just claim MVP honors—he validated an entire league. His arm was a cannon, his knees were Swiss cheese, and his interceptions were legendary, but he also threw for 4,007 yards in a 14-game season and made you believe every time he stepped up. The gunslinger's legacy transcends statistics: he was the first quarterback to win a national championship and a Super Bowl, and he did it all while redefining what a star athlete could be.

Joe Namath Rating Breakdown

Season
Average
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Good
Overall
Slaps
12 years with the Jets

Joe Namath Career Stats via Wikipedia

27,663 Pass Yards
173 Touchdowns
220 INTs
50.1% Comp %
40.8 HAIR

Joe Namath Career Timeline

HEYTC AI
1985 1

Inducted into Pro Football Hall of Fame

Namath was enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, immortalizing his Super Bowl guarantee, style, and impact on the merger-era NFL.

1977 2

Announces Retirement

Namath retired from football at age 34 after his one-year stint with the Rams, closing the book on a Hall of Fame career hampered by major knee surgeries.

Traded to Los Angeles Rams

After 12 seasons with the Jets marred by knee injuries, Namath was traded to the Rams for a late-season stint, where he went 7-7 as a starter in his final NFL action.

1969 2

Jets AFL Champions

Prior to the Super Bowl, Namath guided the Jets through the AFL playoffs, defeating the Oakland Raiders in the AFL Championship Game to reach Super Bowl III.

Super Bowl III MVP - 'I Guarantee It'

Namath famously guaranteed victory and delivered, leading the Jets to a 16-7 upset over the Baltimore Colts in Super Bowl III, completing 17-of-28 for 206 yards to earn MVP honors and legitimize the AFL.

1968 1

AFL Player of the Year & All-Pro

Namath was named AFL Player of the Year and First-Team All-Pro, passing for 3,147 yards and 27 touchdowns while battling chronic knee injuries that would plague his career.

1967 1

First Pro Bowl Selection

Namath made his first of five career Pro Bowl appearances after a stellar season, leading the Jets to playoff contention and showcasing his gunslinger style.

1966 1

Named AFL Rookie of the Year

In his first full season, Namath earned AFL Rookie of the Year honors, throwing for over 3,300 yards and establishing himself as Broadway Joe with his charisma and arm talent.

1965 2

Signs Record $427K Contract

Namath inked a groundbreaking three-year, $427,000 contract with the Jets, the richest deal in pro football history at the time, outbidding NFL teams and solidifying his commitment to the AFL.

Drafted by New York Jets

Joe Namath was selected by the New York Jets in the 1965 AFL Draft out of Alabama, marking the start of his legendary career with the franchise under coach Weeb Ewbank.

13 years in the NFL

Frequently Asked Questions About Joe Namath

How does Brady Cook compare to Joe Namath?

Brady Cook's out there grinding as the Jets' current starter, piecing together a career while Joe's legacy is etched in granite—Super Bowl III guarantee and all, with 27,663 yards and 173 TDs nobody can touch. Cook's building brick by brick; Namath built a monument, Jets' lone ring still gleaming 57 years on.

How does Joe Namath compare to Brady Cook?

Joe Namath isn't in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no bronze bust in Canton despite that Broadway Joe swagger and the Jets' miracle '69 run. Voters snubbed him, maybe eyeing his 50.1 passer rating or off-field flair, but his AFL upset over the Colts echoes louder than any plaque.

What is Joe Namath doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Namath's kicking it in Tequesta, Florida, co-owning the Lucky Shuck oyster spot with inlet views, doting on grandkids next door, and pushing Medicare Coverage Helpline gigs. He's still a Jets ambassador, keynoting on football and business, plus his camp's humming in its 45th year—classic Joe, never fully retired.

How would Joe Namath perform in today's NFL?

Namath would feast in today's pass-happy NFL—think 14-yard completion penalties and no bump-and-run thuggery. His quick release and gunslinger arm, honed in the AFL's wide-open era, translate to 4,000-yard seasons easy; modern protections would've padded his 27,663 yards into Brady territory.

How does Joe Namath compare to Chad Pennington?

Namath edges Chad Pennington as Jets QBs—40.81 passer rating to Chad's 32.41, plus Broadway Joe's got the Super Bowl hardware Pennington chased but never nabbed. Both pocket wizards with injury woes, but Namath's flair and that guarantee game sit higher on HeyTC's All-Time list at #24.