All-Time Cowboys QBs Ranked: Aikman #1, Staubach #2

Quincy Carter

#17 · Dallas Cowboys
Retired 4 Years In The NFL
🏆 SEC Freshman of the Year (1998)
Quincy's
HAIR
8.1
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Quincy Carter or the Cowboys?

Quincy Carter Legacy

HEYTC AI
Quincy Carter was a trailblazer who broke barriers before he ever threw a touchdown pass—the first African-American quarterback to start a season opener for the Dallas Cowboys, drafted 53rd overall in 2001 with Bill Parcells' blessing. He had the moment that mattered most: a fourth-and-14 dagger to Antonio Bryant against Carolina in 2003, snapping a four-year playoff drought and delivering Dallas its first non-losing season since '99. Carter's NFL arc was brief and uneven—6,337 yards, 32 TDs against 37 INTs—but his significance transcended statistics. He represented possibility at a franchise desperate for it, and for one shining season, he delivered exactly what the Cowboys needed: hope and a win that actually meant something.

Quincy Carter Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
3 years with the Cowboys

Quincy Carter Career Stats via Wikipedia

6,337 Pass Yards
32 Touchdowns
37 INTs
0.0% Comp %
8.1 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Quincy Carter

How does Dak Prescott compare to Quincy Carter?

Dak Prescott towers over Quincy Carter like a skyscraper next to a ranch house—Dak's closing in on 40,000 yards and three Pro Bowls while Quincy's four-year flash peaked at 3,302 yards and a playoff push in '03. Carter's arm talent teased Cowboys fans, but Dak's the ironman franchise anchor, turning AT&T into a fortress Quincy only dreamed of.

Is Quincy Carter in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Quincy Carter's not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no bronze bust in Canton for the '03 playoff sparkplug. His 6,337 yards and 32 TDs over 38 starts whisper "what if," not "all-time great," especially with that 71.7 rating trailing the legends who actually got rings and MVPs.

What is Quincy Carter doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Quincy's coaching up the next wave through his QC17 QB Training School in Austin, Texas, drilling kids on pocket presence and intangibles he flashed in Dallas. No broadcasting gigs or charity headlines popping lately, but offseason camps keep his name alive, molding mini-Carters one snap at a time.

How would Quincy Carter perform in today's NFL?

Quincy Carter would've feasted in today's pass-happy NFL—think 56.5% completion and legit deep ball translating to 4,000-yard seasons under rules shielding QBs like glass. His '03 mobility and arm would vibe with McVay schemes, though that 3.9% INT rate might bite against zone-heavy defenses cooked up by these analytics nerds.

How does Quincy Carter compare to Troy Aikman?

Troy Aikman lapped Quincy Carter by light-years—69.66 rating and three Super Bowls versus Quincy's gritty 24.64 and one playoff tease. Aikman's ice-vein precision built a dynasty; Carter was the scrambler who got Dallas to 10-6 once before flaming out, like a promising backup who stole the show for a season.