Stoney Case

#10 · Arizona Cardinals

Retired 4 Years In The NFL

🏆 WAC Offensive Player of the Year (1994)

Stoney's

HAIR

5.1

HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Stoney Case or the Cardinals?

Stoney Case Legacy

HEYTC AI

Stoney Case, the gunslinging gunslinger from Odessa Permian's undefeated '89 state champs, was a college football unicorn at New Mexico—the first I-A QB to rack up 9,000 passing and 1,000 rushing yards, torching defenses for 98 total TDs, fourth all-time back then. Drafted by the Cardinals in '95, he bounced as a scrappy backup through Arizona, Indy, Baltimore, and Detroit, flashing grit in spot starts like his clean two-TD gem against Atlanta. Post-NFL, he lit up Arena League fields before building Hunting Republic into a hunting empire. Case embodies the dual-threat dream that never quite stuck in the pros, but damn if his Lobo legend doesn't linger.

Stoney Case Rating Breakdown

Season

Non-Factor

Fantasy

Non-Factor

Playoffs

Non-Factor

Overall

Cooked

2 years with the Cardinals

Stoney Case Career Stats via Wikipedia

1,826 Pass Yards

4 Touchdowns

15 INTs

0.0% Comp %

5.1 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Stoney Case

How does Kyler Murray compare to Stoney Case?

Kyler Murray's lapped the field on Stoney Case like a Ferrari passing a Schwinn—1,826 yards and four TDs in spot duty versus Kyler's 15,000-plus and franchise-record flair under Kliff Kingsbury. Case's 52.7 completion and 29.1 rating in '95 screamed emergency starter, while Murray's mobile wizardry fits today's game; legacy-wise, Stoney's a footnote to Kyler's saga.

Is Stoney Case in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, Stoney Case ain't in Canton—no bust, no gold jacket, just a third-round flier who flickered for 1,826 yards and four scores across four teams. Hall voters skip journeymen like him, the guy who backed up amid Cardinals chaos, not the Hart or Warner types who carried Desert Bird banners for years.

What is Stoney Case doing now in 2026?

Stoney's swapped pigskins for camo as CEO of Hunting Republic, slinging hunting apparel from his New Mexico roots. Post-NFL stints in Arena League and Ravens/Lions scraps, he's built a steady gig far from gridiron lights—no broadcasting or charity headlines, just entrepreneurial hustle in the wild.

How would Stoney Case perform in today's NFL?

Stoney's dual-threat college chops—9,460 passing yards, 31 rushing TDs at New Mexico—might carve a gadget role today, with pass-happy rules shielding shaky 52.7% arms like his. But 15 picks in 1,826 yards screams backup at best; modern defenses would snack on that '95 pocket presence without elite zip.

How does Stoney Case compare to Jim Hart?

Jim Hart owned Cardinals Sundays for 18 years, 34.49 passer rating and 26,000 yards dwarfing Stoney's emergency 5.11 blip on three starts. Hart slung it deep in the Jake Scott era; Case was the '95 panic button after Jake Plummer's wobbles—same red-and-white threads, worlds apart in snaps and shine.