All-Time Browns QBs Ranked: Graham #1, Kosar #2

Otto Graham

Retired 10 Years In The NFL
🏆 3× NFL champion (1950, 1954, 1955)
Otto's
HAIR
62.6
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Otto Graham or the Browns?

Otto Graham Legacy

HEYTC AI
Otto Graham was the unbreakable heartbeat of Cleveland, "Automatic Otto," who dragged the Browns to 10 straight championship games from 1946-55, winning seven titles across two leagues and stunning the NFL in his debut with a TD pass that shocked the Eagles. A Northwestern multi-tool wizard—passing, running, kicking—whom Paul Brown molded into pro football's first true field general, Graham owned the biggest stages, like his four-TD comeback in the 1950 thriller or his six-TD demolition of Detroit in '54. HeyTC ranks him among the all-time top 20 QBs for that flawless dominance. He passed in 2003 at 82, leaving a legacy as untouchable as his right arm.
Otto Graham passed away on December 17, 2003 at the age of 82.

Otto Graham Rating Breakdown

Season
Elite
Fantasy
Good
Playoffs
Elite
Overall
Sigma
10 years with the Browns

Otto Graham Career Stats via Wikipedia

23,584 Pass Yards
44 Touchdowns
135 INTs
55.8% Comp %
62.6 HAIR

Otto Graham Career Timeline

HEYTC AI
1966 1

Hired as Browns Coach

Graham returned to the Browns as head coach, leading the team for three seasons (1966-68) with a 10-5 playoff appearance in his debut year.

1955 1

Final Championship

In his last season, Graham led the Browns to a 9-2-1 record, Pro Bowl, and fourth NFL Championship, defeating the Rams 38-14 before announcing retirement.

1954 1

Second NFL MVP

Named NFL MVP again with a 9-3 record, Pro Bowl selection, and third championship victory over the Lions in an NFL title game classic.

1953 1

Undefeated Regular Season

Graham orchestrated a perfect 11-0 regular season, earning All-Pro acclaim and an NFL Championship win over the Lions, 17-16.

1951 1

NFL MVP & Pro Bowl

Graham won NFL MVP honors and his first Pro Bowl nod after a 11-1 season, leading Cleveland back to the NFL Championship Game (lost to Rams).

1950 1

NFL Debut & Championship

In the Browns' first NFL season, Graham guided them to an 11-1 record and stunned the league by winning the NFL Championship over the defending champion Eagles, 30-7.

1949 1

AAFC's Final Crown

Graham capped the AAFC era by leading the Browns to a 14-2 record and fourth consecutive championship before the league folded and Cleveland joined the NFL.

1948 1

All-AAFC First Team

Named to the All-AAFC First Team, Graham threw for 2,713 yards and 25 TDs as the Browns went 15-1 and won their third straight AAFC title.

1947 1

First MVP Award

Graham earned his first AAFC MVP after leading the Browns to a perfect 12-0 regular season and another championship, completing 65.7% of passes for 2,631 yards and 25 TDs.

1946 3

AAFC Champions

In his rookie season, Graham led the Browns to a 10-2 record and the AAFC Championship, throwing for 1,834 yards and 17 TDs while showcasing his dual-threat ability.

Signs with Browns

Graham signed with the Cleveland Browns as their starting quarterback under coach Paul Brown, beginning a legendary 10-year tenure with the franchise that would see him lead them to dominance in the AAFC and NFL.

Drafted by Cleveland Rams

Otto Graham was selected in the sixth round (152nd overall) of the 1946 NFL Draft by the Cleveland Rams, who promptly traded him to the expansion Cleveland Browns in the newly formed All-America Football Conference (AAFC).

10 years in the NFL

Frequently Asked Questions About Otto Graham

How does Shedeur Sanders compare to Otto Graham?

Shedeur Sanders, the Browns' current starter, has flashed arm talent and poise, but stacks up like a flashy sports car next to Otto Graham's battle-tested tank—Graham went 10-for-10 in title games, won seven rings, and threw 174 TDs over 23,584 yards in the AAFC/NFL grind. Shedeur's got potential, yet Otto's .814 winning percentage is a relic no modern kid's touching yet.

Is Otto Graham in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Otto Graham is absolutely in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, inducted in 1965 after dragging the Browns to 10 straight championship games and seven titles—talk about a no-brainer enshrinement. The guy's "Automatic Otto" for a reason, with 23,584 yards and that absurd winning clip; Canton's plaque says it all.

How would Otto Graham perform in today's NFL?

Otto Graham would feast in today's pass-happy NFL, where rules shield QBs like him—his 8.63 yards per attempt still owns the all-time record, and with his T-formation scrambling (44 rushing TDs), he'd carve up defenses like he did the AAFC and NFL champs. Imagine that precision in air raid schemes; he'd post 4,000-yard seasons easy.

How does Otto Graham compare to Frank Ryan?

Otto Graham towers over Frank Ryan like a redwood over a shrub—Graham's 86.6-ish rating (blending leagues) and seven rings dwarf Ryan's paltry 33.81 passer rating, even if both wore Browns brown. Ryan snuck a title in '64, but Otto's 10-for-10 championship streak? That's the gulf; Ryan was serviceable, Graham was singular.