All-Time Browns QBs Ranked: Graham #1, Kosar #2

Milt Plum

#16 · Cleveland Browns
Retired 6 Years In The NFL
🏆 Second-team All-Pro (1960)
Milt's
HAIR
31.7
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Milt Plum or the Browns?

Milt Plum Legacy

HEYTC AI
Milt Plum, the steady-handed gunslinger from Penn State who stepped into the breach for a Browns dynasty on the wane, defined an era of precision passing when the NFL still prized arm strength over artistry. What set him apart? Three straight completion percentage crowns from '59-'61 and topping the league's passer rating in '60, all while navigating brutal defenses that turned QBs into piñatas. From Cleveland's huddle to Detroit's roar—where he dueled the greats—Plum's cool efficiency lit up scoreboards across four franchises, a quiet architect of the aerial game's evolution. At 90, his ledger endures as football's unsung metronome.

Milt Plum Rating Breakdown

Season
Great
Fantasy
Good
Playoffs
Subpar
Overall
Delulu
5 years with the Browns

Milt Plum Career Stats via Wikipedia

17,536 Pass Yards
122 Touchdowns
127 INTs
54.0% Comp %
31.7 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Milt Plum

How does Shedeur Sanders compare to Milt Plum?

Milt Plum's the Browns QB with 17,536 yards and 122 TDs over 13 gritty seasons, a real 1960s dropback artist who led the league in completion percentage that year at 60.1%. Shedeur Sanders? Kid's got the arm and poise, but he's chasing echoes of Plum's battle-tested resume—think grizzled vet schooling a flashy rookie in a foggy Cleveland dawn.

Is Milt Plum in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, Milt Plum's not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no bronze bust in Canton for the guy who slung it for the Browns and Lions. Those 2 Pro Bowls and a league-high 60% completion in '60 whisper "underrated," but voters overlooked his 17,536 yards amid flashier names. Still a cult hero for statheads.

What is Milt Plum doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Milt Plum's long retired—turned 92 last year—and keeps a low profile, no splashy broadcasting gigs or charity headlines popping up. The old lion from Penn State likely savors quiet days in Michigan, maybe swapping war stories with Lions buddies over coffee, far from the gridiron glare he once owned.

How would Milt Plum perform in today's NFL?

Plum's pinpoint accuracy—60% in 1960, tops in the league—and 9.19 yards per attempt would've feasted under today's pass-happy rules with no bump-and-run thugs. Imagine him carving up zones like a young Brees, racking up 4,000-yard seasons behind those Lions blockers. Defenses? They'd be begging for mercy.

How does Milt Plum compare to Otto Graham?

Otto Graham owned Cleveland with a sky-high 62.63 passer rating, turning the Browns into monsters; Milt Plum's solid 16.3 mark kept the flame flickering post-Otto, but without the rings or magic. Both franchise pillars, yet Graham's the Ferrari, Plum the reliable pickup truck hauling 122 TDs through the '60s mud.