All-Time Browns QBs Ranked: Graham #1, Kosar #2

Tim Couch

#2 · Cleveland Browns
Retired 5 Years In The NFL
🏆 PFWA All-Rookie Team (1999)
Tim's
HAIR
25.4
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Tim Couch or the Browns?

Tim Couch Legacy

HEYTC AI
Tim Couch, the rocket-armed kid from Hyden, Kentucky, who lit up the SEC like a fireworks show, torching records with Hal Mumme's Air Raid before the Browns made him the No. 1 pick to resurrect their franchise. What made him special? Ice-cold Hail Mary magic—sole QB in NFL history with two 50-yard-plus walk-off touchdown bombs at 0:00, including that Saints stunner for Cleveland's first W and a Jacksonville dagger. He dragged the reborn Browns to the 2002 playoffs, their only dance until 2020, before injuries sidelined the dream. College Hall of Famer now, Couch's legacy is pure what-if grit, a gunslinger who swung for fences in football's heartland.

Tim Couch Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Subpar
Overall
Delulu
5 years with the Browns

Tim Couch Career Stats via Wikipedia

11,131 Pass Yards
64 Touchdowns
67 INTs
59.8% Comp %
25.4 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Tim Couch

How does Shedeur Sanders compare to Tim Couch?

Shedeur Sanders, now the Browns' starter, steps into Tim Couch's shoes as the post-expansion savior who lit up Kentucky with Air Raid magic before Cleveland's meat grinder chewed him up—11,131 yards, 64 TDs over five bruising seasons. Shedeur's got better protection and rules today, but Couch's cannon arm set a bar; early returns say Sanders dodges the same fate, unlike Tim's thumb-shattering woes.

Is Tim Couch in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Tim Couch ain't in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no Canton bronze bust for the No. 1 pick who dragged a dismal Browns squad to the 2002 playoffs amid endless injuries. He's got College Football HOF honors for his UK fireworks, though, where he shattered records like 83% completions in a game. Cleveland's ghosts keep him out.

What is Tim Couch doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Tim Couch's chilling in Lexington as a partner at Meridian Wealth Management with his brother Greg, crunching numbers nationwide. He dips into broadcasting gigs like old SEC Network stints and stays community-active, bankrolling Kentucky's football digs and Gill Heart Institute. Smarter gig than dodging Dawg Pound blitzes.

How would Tim Couch perform in today's NFL?

Couch's live-wire arm and quick release would've feasted in today's pass-happy NFL—think quicker drops, no-tuck rules shielding his fragile frame from '99's savage hits. That 25.35% adjusted rating? Modern O-lines and RPOs bump it toward relevance, not bust. He'd be a poor man's Geno Smith, dodging Tim Couch 2.0 labels.

How does Tim Couch compare to Otto Graham?

Tim Couch and Otto Graham both owned the Browns' QB throne, but Otto's 62.63% adjusted rating towers over Couch's 25.35 like a '50s championship ring over a participation trophy. Graham went 10-0 in titles; Tim battled expansion purgatory with 11k yards. Same orange helmet, worlds apart—Otto's the GOAT, Couch the gritty sequel nobody rewatched.