All-Time Seahawks QBs Ranked: Wilson #1, Hasselbeck #2

Charlie Whitehurst

#6 · Seattle Seahawks
Retired 3 Years In The NFL
🏆 Second-team All-ACC (2005)
Charlie's
HAIR
7.6
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Charlie Whitehurst or the Seahawks?

Charlie Whitehurst Legacy

HEYTC AI
Charlie Whitehurst was a journeyman's journeyman—the kind of quarterback who showed up, did his job, and never complained about the depth chart. A third-round pick out of Clemson in 2006, he bounced through seven seasons across five teams, but his signature moment came on a Sunday night in Seattle when he stepped in and beat the Rams to clinch the NFC West, reminding everyone why Pete Carroll believed in him. His 2014 season with Tennessee was his best work—career highs across the board, including seven touchdown passes—but Whitehurst's real legacy is being the reliable backup who understood his role. Not every quarterback gets to be the hero; some just get to be professional, and that was Whitehurst's quiet strength.

Charlie Whitehurst Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
2 years with the Seahawks

Charlie Whitehurst Career Stats via Wikipedia

2,463 Pass Yards
11 Touchdowns
8 INTs
55.3% Comp %
7.6 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Charlie Whitehurst

How does Sam Darnold compare to Charlie Whitehurst?

Sam Darnold, now holding down the Seahawks starter gig, towers over Charlie Whitehurst's journeyman backup days—Darnold's got arm talent and mobility Whitehurst could only dream of, while Charlie's 2,463 career yards and 11 TDs scream eternal clipboard holder. It's like comparing a sports car to a reliable old pickup; Whitehurst's legacy is that one wild 2010 Rams win, but Darnold's built for the long haul.

Is Charlie Whitehurst in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Charlie Whitehurst's not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no Canton bronze bust for the Clipboard Jesus. His 74.9 career rating and spot starts across seven teams with the Seahawks, Chargers, Titans, Colts, and Browns didn't scream elite. Guy was a solid pro, but Hall? That's for the Hasselbecks, not the emergency sliders.

What is Charlie Whitehurst doing now in 2026?

As of early 2026, Charlie Whitehurst's off the grid—no splashy broadcasting gigs or big charity headlines popping up. Last whispers tie him to that "Clipboard Jesus" persona, maybe chilling post-2016 Browns stint, but he's not lighting up business ventures or sidelines. Classic fade-out for a backup who peaked with Jewel's national title game crew.

How would Charlie Whitehurst perform in today's NFL?

Whitehurst's game—55% completions, pocket presence, no panic—might carve a niche in today's pass-happy NFL with rules shielding QBs like never before. His 2014 Titans stretch (1,326 yards, 7 TDs) hints at starter flashes, but weak arm and mobility would've capped him as a Geno Smith type: reliable bridge guy, not Mahomes.

How does Charlie Whitehurst compare to Matt Hasselbeck?

Matt Hasselbeck lapped Charlie Whitehurst in Seattle lore—a 38.7 rating to Charlie's measly 7.63 in those shared Hawks years, with Matt's Pro Bowls and playoff heroics dwarfing Whitehurst's emergency Rams upset. Both franchise bridge QBs, sure, but Hasselbeck was the Ferrari; Charlie, the dependable rental when Tarvaris Jackson flamed out.