All-Time Broncos QBs Ranked: Elway #1, Manning #2

John Elway

Retired 17 Years In The NFL
🏆 2× Super Bowl champion (XXXII, XXXIII)
John's
HAIR
71.8
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about John Elway or the Broncos?

John Elway Legacy

HEYTC AI
John Elway was the gunslinging Stanford kid traded into Denver royalty, a rocket-armed maestro who turned the Broncos into perennial contenders through sheer fourth-quarter sorcery—47 game-winning drives that left defenders dazed and Mile High roaring. Critics called him one-dimensional early on, but Elway's laser passes to unreachable spots and scrambles for Super Bowl rushing scores proved them dead wrong, silencing doubters with back-to-back rings in '97 and '98, claiming MVP in XXXIII at 37. The Duke owned Denver's soul for 16 seasons, a Hall of Fame icon whose competitive fire etched him among the all-time elite.

John Elway Rating Breakdown

Season
Good
Fantasy
Good
Playoffs
Elite
Overall
Sigma
16 years with the Broncos

John Elway Career Stats via Wikipedia

51,475 Pass Yards
33 Touchdowns
226 INTs
56.9% Comp %
71.8 HAIR
148-82 Record

John Elway Career Timeline

HEYTC AI
2004 1

Pro Football Hall of Fame Induction

Enshrined in Canton on first ballot, celebrated for revolutionary deep-ball accuracy, mobility, and 47 game-winning drives (most ever); Broncos retired his No. 7.

1998 2

Retires After Record-Setting Career

Announced retirement at age 38 after 16 seasons with Denver (never played for Indy), finishing with 56,836 yards (2nd all-time then), 300 TDs (then-record), 9 Pro Bowls, and 5 Super Bowl trips.

Second Super Bowl Triumph

Capped career with back-to-back titles, Broncos went 14-2 and crushed Atlanta 34-19 in Super Bowl XXXIII; Elway passed for 336 yards and 1 TD in the 'Helicopter' play highlight.

1997 1

First Super Bowl Win

Led Broncos to 12-4 record and first Super Bowl victory, demolishing Green Bay 31-24 in Super Bowl XXXII; Elway threw for 336 yards and 1 TD, rushed for 19 yards, and earned game MVP.

1996 1

Single-Season Record Rushing Yards for QB

Set NFL record for quarterback rushing yards in a season with 349 on 65 carries (5.4 avg), adding 10 rushing TDs while passing for 4,034 yards and 26 TDs; 13th Pro Bowl.

1993 1

All-Pro First Team

Named First-Team All-Pro for the first time, leading NFL with 4,030 passing yards, 25 TDs, and a 92.0 passer rating en route to another Pro Bowl and playoff berth.

1990 1

Major Back Injury

Suffered a significant throwing shoulder injury late in the season, requiring surgery and sidelining him for part of 1991 rehab; still made Pro Bowl but Broncos missed playoffs.

1989 1

Back-to-Back Pro Bowls

Earned third consecutive Pro Bowl honor (fourth overall) with 3,309 yards, 19 TDs, and added 335 rushing yards, solidifying his reputation as the league's premier gunslinger.

1987 2

Second Straight Super Bowl

Advanced to Super Bowl XXII, beating Houston and Indianapolis in playoffs, but fell 42-10 to Washington as Doug Williams torched the secondary; Elway threw for 336 yards and 1 TD.

NFL MVP Award

Named NFL MVP during the strike-shortened season, completing 60.4% of passes for 3,198 yards, 19 TDs, and just 8 INTs while leading Denver to a 10-4-1 record amid replacement player chaos.

1986 2

First Super Bowl Appearance

Guided Broncos to Super Bowl XXI, upsetting Cleveland and New England in the playoffs, but lost 39-20 to the Giants as Elway threw for 304 yards and 1 TD in a valiant effort dubbed 'The Fumble' game.

First Pro Bowl Nod

Elway earned his first Pro Bowl selection after leading the Broncos to a 11-5 record, throwing for 3,389 yards and 19 TDs while rushing for 257 yards and 3 scores in a dual-threat breakout year.

1983 2

Signs with Broncos

Elway joined the Denver Broncos as a rookie, starting 10 games and throwing for 1,663 yards, 7 TDs, and 14 INTs in his debut season, showcasing the arm talent that made him the No. 1 pick.

Drafted by Baltimore Colts

John Elway was selected as the first overall pick in the first round of the 1983 NFL Draft by the Baltimore Colts out of Stanford. He was immediately traded to the Denver Broncos for RB Don Woods, LB Chris Hinton, and a conditional pick after refusing to play for Indianapolis.

17 years in the NFL

Frequently Asked Questions About John Elway

How does Bo Nix compare to John Elway?

Bo Nix, the Broncos' steady second-year gunslinger, has Elway's poise under Sean Payton, but he's chasing a legend who threw for 51,475 yards, 300 TDs, and those back-to-back Super Bowls after years of heartbreak. Nix's got the arm talent Elway raved about on Rich Eisen, yet he's miles from toppling the Duke's throne—think promising apprentice, not the master.

Is John Elway in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Damn right John Elway's in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, inducted in 2004 after redefining QB grit with two rings and that cannon arm. It's where icons like him belong, right next to the all-timers who dragged Denver to glory when it mattered most.

What is John Elway doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Elway's still Broncos royalty, hyping Bo Nix's growth and Sean Payton's squad on Rich Eisen while scooping up a National Football Foundation award and premiering his Netflix doc at the Denver Film Fest—pure nostalgia fuel. Guy's living the good life, dispensing wisdom without the clipboard.

How would John Elway perform in today's NFL?

Elway would feast in today's pass-happy NFL—those rules coddling QBs suit his rocket arm and scrambler legs like a glove. Imagine 51,475 yards plus in this era; he'd shred secondaries, pile up MVP nods, and maybe snag three rings instead of two. Vintage rocket meets modern playground.

How does John Elway compare to Brian Griese?

Elway towers over Brian Griese like a mountain over a foothill—71.78 passer rating to Griese's limp 29.64, plus two Super Bowls versus Griese's injury-riddled backup stint. Both Broncos QBs, sure, but Elway's the supernova who lit Mile High; Griese was solid relief, not the headliner.