All-Time 49ers QBs Ranked: Montana #1, Young #2

Joe Montana

Retired 15 Years In The NFL
🏆 4× Super Bowl champion (XVI, XIX, XXIII, XXIV)
Joe's
HAIR
85.2
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Joe Montana or the 49ers?

Joe Montana Legacy

HEYTC AI
Joe Montana wasn't just a quarterback—he was Joe Cool, the unflappable gunslinger from a Pennsylvania steel town who turned the impossible into art. Drafted in the third round, he redefined clutch with "The Catch" to Dwight Clark in the 1981 NFC Championship, then orchestrated that 92-yard miracle drive in Super Bowl XXIII, rifling the winner with 34 seconds left. Four rings with the 49ers, three Super Bowl MVPs, and 31 fourth-quarter comebacks later, Montana's ice-water veins made him the ultimate winner, ranking among the all-time elite. Even in Kansas City, he authored magic, proving legends don't fade.

Joe Montana Rating Breakdown

Season
Elite
Fantasy
Great
Playoffs
Elite
Overall
Aura
13 years with the 49ers

Joe Montana Career Stats via Wikipedia

40,551 Pass Yards
20 Touchdowns
139 INTs
63.2% Comp %
85.2 HAIR
117-47 Record

Joe Montana Career Timeline

HEYTC AI
2025 1

Remains among NFL all-time passing leaders

As of the mid-2020s, Joe Montana remains high on the NFL’s all-time passing yards list with 40,551 career passing yards accumulated between 1979 and 1994, reflecting his long-term productivity as a franchise quarterback for both the 49ers and Chiefs.

2000 1

Inducted into Pro Football Hall of Fame

Joe Montana was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2000 in recognition of his outstanding NFL career, which featured four Super Bowl victories, two Associated Press MVP awards, eight Pro Bowl selections, and several playoff passing records at the time of his retirement.

1994 1

Final playoff appearance and retirement announcement

Montana played one more season with the Kansas City Chiefs in 1994, leading them to the playoffs before a loss to the Miami Dolphins in the Wild Card round. After that season, he announced his retirement, concluding a 16-year NFL career that included four Super Bowl championships and numerous playoff passing records.

1993 2

Leads Chiefs to division title and AFC Championship Game

In his first season with the Kansas City Chiefs in 1993, Montana proved he still had elite ability by leading the team to its first division title in 22 years and an appearance in the AFC Championship Game. His performance revitalized the franchise and demonstrated his effectiveness even late in his career.

Traded from 49ers to Kansas City Chiefs

In April 1993, the San Francisco 49ers traded Joe Montana to the Kansas City Chiefs after Steve Young had taken over as the starting quarterback. This move ended Montana’s 13-year tenure with the 49ers and began a new phase of his career in Kansas City.

1991 1

Misses nearly two full seasons due to injury

Following the injuries suffered at the end of the 1990 season, Montana missed almost all of the 1991 and 1992 seasons for the 49ers. By the time he was fully healthy again, the team had committed to Steve Young as their starter, setting the stage for Montana’s eventual departure from San Francisco.

1990 2

Injury in NFC Championship Game

In the 1990 season, Montana led the 49ers to a 14–2 record and an appearance in the NFC Championship Game, but he was knocked out of the loss to the New York Giants with injuries. Those injuries sidelined him for nearly all of the next two seasons, opening the door for Steve Young to take over as San Francisco’s starting quarterback.

Back-to-back Super Bowl titles and league MVP stretch

Montana and the 49ers repeated as champions by winning Super Bowl XXIV following the 1989 season, giving him four Super Bowl victories overall and three Super Bowl MVP awards in his career. Over this period he was also named Associated Press NFL MVP twice and earned multiple first-team All-Pro and Pro Bowl selections, cementing his status as the league’s top quarterback.

1989 1

Third Super Bowl win and Super Bowl MVP (Super Bowl XXIII)

In the 1988 season, Montana led the 49ers back to the Super Bowl, where they won Super Bowl XXIII. His late game-winning drive against the Cincinnati Bengals became one of the most iconic moments of his career and added a third Super Bowl title to his résumé.

1984 1

Historic 1984 season and second Super Bowl title

During the 1984 season, Montana guided the 49ers to a dominant 15–1 record and a victory in Super Bowl XIX, his second Super Bowl championship. This season is often cited as one of the most complete team and quarterback campaigns of the era, further elevating his status as an elite passer.

1981 1

Wins first Super Bowl with 49ers (Super Bowl XVI)

In the 1981 season, Joe Montana became the full-time starter for the San Francisco 49ers and led the team to a 13–3 record, culminating in a victory in Super Bowl XVI. This was Montana’s first Super Bowl win and firmly established him as one of the league’s premier quarterbacks.

1979 1

Drafted by San Francisco 49ers

Joe Montana was selected in the third round of the 1979 NFL Draft by the San Francisco 49ers after leading Notre Dame to the 1977 national championship and a famous comeback in the 1979 Cotton Bowl. He was a third-round pick in the 1979 NFL Draft by the 49ers, where head coach Bill Walsh envisioned him as the future franchise quarterback.

15 years in the NFL

Frequently Asked Questions About Joe Montana

How does Brock Purdy compare to Joe Montana?

Brock Purdy's got that same cool-as-ice vibe Joe Montana brought to the pocket—no cannon arm, no gazelle legs, but pinpoint accuracy and unflappable poise that wins games. Montana himself raved about Purdy's catchable balls threading keyholes, his prep work, and that quiet command, saying it's rare for the ball to come in too hot. Purdy's no Montana yet—four rings tower over zero—but he's channeling that 49ers magic minus the Super Bowl hardware.

Is Joe Montana in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Damn right Joe Montana's in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, strolling in during 2000 after redefining clutch with those four Lombardi trophies and 40,551 yards. It's like inducting Michael Jordan into basketball's shrine—undebatable, the guy who made "The Catch" to Dwight Clark eternal and turned the Niners into a dynasty. No brainer for Canton.

What is Joe Montana doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Joe's chilling in the good life—dipping into business ventures, teeing up golf stories from his Montana ranch, and popping up on podcasts dissecting 49ers film like that recent chat comparing himself to Purdy. He's not calling games full-time, but his charity golf tourneys keep the legacy rolling, all while staying sharp on what's next for the Bay Area signal-callers.

How would Joe Montana perform in today's NFL?

Joe Montana would carve up today's NFL like a hot knife through butter—pass-happy rules, no more mugging receivers, and protections galore favoring his wizardry. That 63.2% completion clip and ice-veined drives? Imagine "The Drive" in empty-backfields with McCaffrey leaking out. Arm strength? Who cares when you're threading needles in Shanahan's scheme— he'd feast on these soft zones.

How does Joe Montana compare to Steve Young?

Joe Montana edges Steve Young in the pocket passer Olympics—85.15 passer rating to Young's wild 53.48 wait, scratch that, Young's actually 96.8 career mark towers in raw efficiency, but Montana's the closer with four rings to Young's three. Both Niners immortals, Joe's the surgeon dissecting defenses, Steve the scrambler torching 'em mobile. Franchise flip: Montana built it, Young reloaded it. Pure QB nirvana tandem.