All-Time Chiefs QBs Ranked: Mahomes #1, Dawson #2

Brodie Croyle

#12 · Kansas City Chiefs
Retired 6 Years In The NFL
🏆 2006 AT&T Cotton Bowl Classic MVP
Brodie's
HAIR
7.7
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Brodie Croyle or the Chiefs?

Brodie Croyle Legacy

HEYTC AI
Brodie Croyle was the kid everybody wanted to be—a generational talent from Alabama who arrived in Kansas City with the pedigree and arm talent to change a franchise. Instead, he became a cautionary tale about what injuries can steal from a career. That 2006 Cotton Bowl MVP moment felt like the beginning of something special, but shoulder and knee issues conspired to limit what could've been. He threw more interceptions than touchdowns in the NFL, a brutal reality that obscures what he accomplished at Alabama, where he rewrote the record books and led the Crimson Tide to a top-10 ranking. Sometimes the greatest what-ifs are the ones we never get to see unfold.

Brodie Croyle Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
5 years with the Chiefs

Brodie Croyle Career Stats via Wikipedia

1,669 Pass Yards
8 Touchdowns
9 INTs
0.0% Comp %
7.7 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Brodie Croyle

How does Patrick Mahomes compare to Brodie Croyle?

Mahomes operates in a different stratosphere—literally a future Hall of Famer with multiple Super Bowls and MVPs, while Croyle threw eight career touchdown passes. It's like comparing a Tesla to a reliable Honda Civic. Both wore red, but Mahomes is redefining what's possible at the position while Croyle learned the hardest lesson a backup can: sometimes your greatest impact comes off the field.

Is Brodie Croyle in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, Croyle never made Canton, and his 1,669 career passing yards won't change anyone's mind. Six seasons in the league with limited starting opportunities—he's a footnote in Chiefs history, not a Hall of Famer. His real legacy isn't measured in Pro Football Hall votes anyway.

What is Brodie Croyle doing now in 2026?

Croyle's been running Big Oak Ranch as CEO for over a decade, the children's home his father founded that's now served nearly 3,000 kids across 28 homes. He still speaks to quarterback clubs about leadership and priorities, mixing football wisdom with his genuine passion for helping neglected and abandoned children. The guy traded the spotlight for something that actually matters.

How would Brodie Croyle perform in today's NFL?

Croyle's arm talent and decision-making wouldn't translate to today's pass-happy NFL. He'd get exposed in a league where backup QBs need to be ready to sling it 40 times a game. His best quality—understanding how to lead from a backup role—remains timeless, but the modern game demands a different skill set entirely.

How does Brodie Croyle compare to Len Dawson?

Len Dawson laps Croyle like it's not even close. Dawson's a Hall of Famer with a Super Bowl ring and a 51.37 rating; Croyle managed 7.71 with eight TDs in six seasons. Different eras, sure, but Dawson was a franchise cornerstone while Croyle was a capable backup who found his true calling elsewhere.