All-Time Chiefs QBs Ranked: Mahomes #1, Dawson #2

Tyler Palko

#4 · Kansas City Chiefs
Retired 2 Years In The NFL
🏆 2× Second-team Big East (2004, 2005)
Tyler's
HAIR
5.0
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Tyler Palko or the Chiefs?

Tyler Palko Legacy

HEYTC AI
Tyler Palko, the scrappy Pitt gunslinger from Imperial, PA, who grew up snapping up state titles at West Allegheny before owning the Panthers' huddle as a two-time captain and Offensive MVP. What etched him in gold and blue forever? That electric 2004 shootout at No. 24 Notre Dame—five TD bombs as the visitor, then a postgame mic-drop expletive that sent Panther Nation into delirious lore, clinching a 41-38 heart-stopper. A program legend ranking among Pitt's all-time QB elite with Marino and Pickett, Palko chased the NFL dream as a journeyman across Saints, Chiefs, Alouettes, and beyond—proof that Pitt pride fuels the unlikeliest underdogs.

Tyler Palko Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
2 years with the Chiefs

Tyler Palko Career Stats via Wikipedia

831 Pass Yards
2 Touchdowns
7 INTs
0.0% Comp %
5.0 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Tyler Palko

How does Patrick Mahomes compare to Tyler Palko?

Patrick Mahomes towers over Tyler Palko like a Ferrari next to a '72 Pinto—Mahomes owns Arrowhead with three Super Bowls and no-look wizardry, while Palko's Chiefs legacy is a gritty 831 yards, 2 TDs, and a 4.99 rating in spot duty. Both lefties who dreamed big, but Mahomes rewrote the script; Palko was the understudy who got one act.

Is Tyler Palko in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Tyler Palko won't be strolling into Canton anytime soon—no bust waiting for the Pitt gunslinger who lit up college fields but managed just 831 NFL yards. Hall voters chase rings and stats, not cult-hero backups who went undrafted and bounced from Saints to Chiefs. Legends like Marino from Pitt set a higher bar.

What is Tyler Palko doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Tyler Palko's crushing it as Chief Revenue Officer at Solutions 21, scaling their Next Leader Now program for Fortune-level execs while founding TC House to build independent homes for folks with Down syndrome. Keynote gigs at Pitt luncheons keep his fire lit—football's field general now leads boardrooms from Overland Park.

How would Tyler Palko perform in today's NFL?

Palko's lefty arm and Pitt grit might snag him a practice squad nod today, where pass-happy rules and RPOs favor quick decisions over arm talent alone. His 66 college TDs translate better in this no-huddle era, but without elite zip or wheels, he'd be a Chad Henne type—reliable in camp, third-string in September.

How does Tyler Palko compare to Len Dawson?

Len Dawson mastered the Chiefs' kingdom with a 51.37 rating, AFL crowns, and that Super Bowl mustache, while Palko's 4.99 blur in five years screams emergency filler. Both franchise QBs in red, but Dawson was the maestro; Palko the halftime sub who handed it off and prayed. Apples to arrow slingshots.