All-Time Eagles QBs Ranked: Hurts #1, McNabb #2

Scott Tinsley

Philadelphia Eagles
Retired 1 Year In The NFL
Scott's
HAIR
6.6
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Scott Tinsley or the Eagles?

Scott Tinsley Legacy

HEYTC AI
Scott Tinsley's NFL career was a footnote—one season as a quarterback in the pros—but his real legacy was built in West Virginia's high school and college ranks, where he became a tireless builder of programs. After a brief stint at West Virginia State, Tinsley found his true calling at Nitro High School, where he spent 13 years establishing a football culture that outlasted his tenure. He wasn't chasing championships or national recognition; he was the steady hand developing young players in small-town West Virginia, the kind of coach who understood that football's greatest gift isn't winning games—it's shaping character. That's the Tinsley story: quiet competence in places where it mattered most.

Scott Tinsley Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
1 year with the Eagles

Scott Tinsley Career Stats via Wikipedia

0 Pass Yards
0 Touchdowns
0 INTs
0.0% Comp %
6.6 HAIR
17-56 Record

Frequently Asked Questions About Scott Tinsley

How does Jalen Hurts compare to Scott Tinsley?

Jalen Hurts towers over Scott Tinsley like a skyscraper next to a shed—Hurts is torching defenses weekly as Philly's franchise anchor, while Tinsley flickered for three replacement games in '87, going 3-for-4 with a 71.7 rating and 50 yards for the strike-breaker Eagles. Hurts' dual-threat chaos would make Tinsley's cameo feel like a preseason warm-up.

Is Scott Tinsley in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Scott Tinsley ain't in Canton—his three-game stint as a '87 replacement player doesn't scream Hall of Fame bling, despite those three TDs and 637 career yards. The busts there are for guys who reshaped the game, not scab QBs who vanished after the strike ended. Solid trivia nugget, though.

What is Scott Tinsley doing now in 2026?

No fresh intel on Scott Tinsley in 2026—he's stayed off the radar since that '87 Eagles cameo, no broadcasts, businesses, or charity headlines popping. Picture the ultimate ghost: 637 yards lifetime, then poof into civilian life. If he's out there slinging insurance or coaching pee wee, it's under wraps.

How would Scott Tinsley perform in today's NFL?

Tinsley's quick-release arm might sneak a few checkdowns in today's pass-happy NFL with no bump-and-run thugs, but his 3-4 TD-INT line screams third-stringer against blitzes. Modern rules favor gunslingers; he'd be that emergency mop-up guy, not starting over mobile maestros like Hurts. Fun what-if, zero shot at glory.

How does Scott Tinsley compare to Donovan McNabb?

Donovan McNabb lapped Scott Tinsley like a Ferrari passing a go-kart—Donovan's 46.44 career rating fueled Eagles playoff runs, while Tinsley's 71.7 came off four puny completions in '87 strike duty. Both Philly QBs, sure, but McNabb was the engine; Tinsley, a spark plug that lasted one tank of gas.