All-Time Bears QBs Ranked: McMahon #1, Wade #2

Shane Matthews

#9 · Chicago Bears
Retired 5 Years In The NFL
🏆 2× Second-team All-American (1991, 1992)
Shane's
HAIR
10.7
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Shane Matthews or the Bears?

Shane Matthews Legacy

HEYTC AI
Shane Matthews, the Pascagoula gunslinger who lit up the SEC like a Swamp Saturday supernova, was Florida's pocket maestro—two-time Player of the Year, three-time All-SEC stud, dropping dimes that earned him dual All-American nods and a forever spot in the Gators' pantheon. Undrafted in '93, he bounced through a NFL journeyman's odyssey—Bears, Panthers, Skins, Bucs, Bengals, Bills, Dolphins—always the savvy clipboard king ready to spark a comeback. Post-gridiron, he molded high school phenoms in Florida and even quarterbacked the XFL's Orlando Guardians. The ultimate underdog tale: proof that Gator grit outshines the spotlight.

Shane Matthews Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Good
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
NPC
4 years with the Bears

Shane Matthews Career Stats via Wikipedia

4,756 Pass Yards
31 Touchdowns
24 INTs
0.0% Comp %
10.7 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Shane Matthews

How does Caleb Williams compare to Shane Matthews?

Caleb Williams, the Bears' electric 2025 starter with Heisman flair, towers over Shane Matthews's journeyman run—4,756 yards and 31 TDs across six spot starts mostly in Chicago's Soldier Field shadows. Caleb's got arm talent and mobility Matthews could only dream of in the '90s grind; one's a franchise savior in waiting, the other's a gritty backup who peaked with 1,645 yards in '99.

Is Shane Matthews in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Shane Matthews isn't in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no bust in Canton for the Florida Gator who slung it for the Bears, Skins, and Bills. With just 32 games, 4,756 yards, and 31 TDs over 14 seasons as a career third-stringer, he's a cult figure for us old-school Bears fans, not a gold jacket guy.

What is Shane Matthews doing now in 2026?

As of 2026, Shane Matthews keeps a low profile post-NFL, no splashy broadcasting gigs or big charity headlines popping up. The ex-Gator likely coaches youth ball or runs local QB camps in Florida, staying true to his backup roots—quiet life after that 2007 retirement, far from the gridiron spotlight he rarely owned.

How would Shane Matthews perform in today's NFL?

Shane's quick-release pocket game—65% completion in spurts like his 1,645-yard '99—would feast under today's pass-happy rules with RPOs and no-touch DBs. But lacking elite arm zip or wheels, he'd be a Chad Pennington type: solid bridge QB in spread offenses, maybe 3,500 yards a year if handed keys, not a weekly stud.

How does Shane Matthews compare to Jim McMahon?

Shane Matthews's 10.65 passer rating (wait, that glitchy lowball screams partial stats) pales next to Jim McMahon's legit 45.04 across his wild Bears tenure—McMahon torched defenses with that mullet swagger and '85 magic. Both Chicago QBs, but Shane was the emergency phone, Jim the punk-rock starter who delivered a ring.