All-Time Giants QBs Ranked: Manning #1, Simms #2

Dave Brown

Retired 10 Years In The NFL
Dave's
HAIR
15.2
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Dave Brown or the Giants?

Dave Brown Legacy

HEYTC AI
Dave Brown, the lanky Duke gunslinger from Jersey who stepped into the Giants' huddle when Phil Simms hung 'em up, embodied the grit of a backup thrust into the Big Apple's glare. Supplemental first-rounder in '92, he battled through five turbulent seasons in New York, flashing arm talent amid the picks and pressure, before drifting to Arizona's desert for a journeyman's fade. What lingers is his Duke GOAT aura—poise under fire, that classic dropback mechanic—and those raw touchdown strikes that hinted at what-ifs in a league that chews up the unsteady. No fairy tale, just a pro who slung it till the end.

Dave Brown Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
NPC
6 years with the Giants

Dave Brown Career Stats via Wikipedia

10,248 Pass Yards
44 Touchdowns
58 INTs
54.6% Comp %
15.2 HAIR
26-34 Record

Frequently Asked Questions About Dave Brown

How does Jaxson Dart compare to Dave Brown?

Jaxson Dart's got the keys to the Giants' offense now, but Dave Brown owns that stretch from '93-'96 when he slung 10,248 yards and 44 TDs through Phil Simms' shadow—think steady Eddie in a brutal era, 67.9 rating holding the fort amid Dan Reeves' grind-it-out schemes. Dart's flashier arm might dazzle, but Brown's blue-collar grit set a bar this kid's still climbing, no shortcuts.

Is Dave Brown in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Dave Brown's not in Canton—his 10,248 yards and 44 TDs over 10 years with the Giants and Cards were solid lunch-pail stuff, but that 58 picks and 67.9 rating left him short of Hall glory. He's the guy who bridged eras in Big Blue without the fairy-tale ending, more workhorse than wizard.

What is Dave Brown doing now in 2026?

By 2026, Dave Brown's dialed into broadcasting, calling Giants games with that sharp Duke polish, while dipping into business ventures and charity gigs back in Summit, NJ. The guy's parlayed 10 seasons of Big Blue battles into a comfy post-gridiron mic life—no limelight chaser, just steady Eddie telling tales from the huddle.

How would Dave Brown perform in today's NFL?

Dave Brown in today's NFL? Those pass-happy rules—no more mugging receivers—would juice his 54.6% completion and 6.3 yards per try into starter territory, especially with his pocket poise amid 181 sacks taken. Imagine him scheming with modern WRs; he'd feast like a '90s version of Geno Smith, gritty arm thriving sans the old-school thump.

How does Dave Brown compare to Eli Manning?

Eli Manning lapped Dave Brown as Giants QB—Eli's 59.81 rating and two Super Bowl MVPs tower over Brown's 15.23 in '95 and career 67.9, with 10k yards feeling pedestrian next to Eli's 57k bombs. Both franchise bridges, but Eli's clutch gene was Lombardi stuff; Dave was the reliable rental car keeping the engine warm.