All-Time Giants QBs Ranked: Manning #1, Simms #2

Jerry Golsteyn

#12 · New York Giants
Retired 5 Years In The NFL
Jerry's
HAIR
8.6
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Jerry Golsteyn or the Giants?

Jerry Golsteyn Legacy

HEYTC AI
Jerry Golsteyn was a journeyman's journeyman—a 12th-round pick from Northern Illinois who refused to disappear quietly, bouncing through five NFL teams and even taking a detour through the AFA because, well, somebody had to. His 36.2 passer rating tells you everything about his on-field struggles, but what matters is the grit: a 6'4" competitor who kept fighting for roster spots across eight NFL seasons when lesser men would've quit. Golsteyn never became the guy, but he stayed in the game longer than most had any right to expect. That's its own kind of legacy—the guy who showed up, competed, and proved that not every quarterback's story ends in glory. Sometimes it just ends in respect.

Jerry Golsteyn Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
2 years with the Giants

Jerry Golsteyn Career Stats via Wikipedia

1,077 Pass Yards
2 Touchdowns
13 INTs
0.0% Comp %
8.6 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Jerry Golsteyn

How does Jaxson Dart compare to Jerry Golsteyn?

Jaxson Dart's got the keys to the Giants' offense now, but Jerry Golsteyn's the grizzled '70s benchmark—1,077 yards, 2 TDs, and a measly 8.59 rating across five starts in that brutal 2-11-1 dumpster fire of '77. Dart's flashier arm would lap Golsteyn's plodding style, yet Jerry's the low bar that makes Jaxson's every completion feel like a win over Yankee Stadium ghosts.

Is Jerry Golsteyn in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Jerry Golsteyn's not chilling in Canton—no bust, no gold jacket, zero Hall calls despite that cult-classic stint as Big Blue's 12th-round Hail Mary in '76. Guy threw for 1,077 yards lifetime, but eight picks to two scores in '77 sealed his spot on the "what if" shelf, not the shrine.

What is Jerry Golsteyn doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Jerry Golsteyn's off the grid—no broadcasts, no charity splash, no business headlines tying back to his Giants days. Last whispers from the '90s have him grinding in fringe leagues like the Orlando Americans, but these days? Probably golfing quietly, far from any NFL radar.

How would Jerry Golsteyn perform in today's NFL?

Golsteyn's shotgun arm might sneak a few chunk plays under today's pass-happy rules—no more eight-man fronts teeing off on QBs. But with 1,077 career yards and that -0.2 ANY/A bomb, he'd be a camp arm at best, not surviving blitzes without modern protection or a prayer.

How does Jerry Golsteyn compare to Eli Manning?

Eli Manning owned the Giants' throne with 57,023 yards and a 59.81 rating over 16 years of heroics; Golsteyn? Five starts, 1,077 yards, 8.59 rating—like comparing a Super Bowl slinger to a Yankee Stadium scrimmage quarterback who got shelled in the '77 debacle. Eli's the king; Jerry's the footnote.