All-Time Giants QBs Ranked: Manning #1, Simms #2

Jim Crocicchia

#2 · New York Giants
Retired 2 Years In The NFL
Jim's
HAIR
7.1
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Jim Crocicchia or the Giants?

Jim Crocicchia Legacy

HEYTC AI
Jim Crocicchia, the lanky Penn Quakers gunslinger from Waterbury's gritty streets, crashed the NFL party as an undrafted Giant in '87, stepping into the breach like a classic underdog tale. With Phil Simms sidelined, this 6'2" Ivy Leaguer aired it out for his one shining Big Blue moment—a 46-yard dart for six, no picks, pure poise under pressure. Then he bolted to the Arena League's New York Knights, owning the cage as their startup signal-caller. Crocicchia's legacy? The ultimate journeyman heartbeat, proving football's magic lives in the fleeting what-ifs, not just the Hall plaques.

Jim Crocicchia Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
1 year with the Giants

Jim Crocicchia Career Stats via Wikipedia

0 Pass Yards
1 Touchdowns
0 INTs
0.0% Comp %
7.1 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Jim Crocicchia

How does Jaxson Dart compare to Jim Crocicchia?

Jaxson Dart's got the Giants' starting gig now, but stacking him against Jim Crocicchia's one-game NFL cameo—89 yards, one TD in a 3-14 disaster—is like pitting a prospect against a guy who survived arena chaos with 26 TDs for the Knights. Dart's got modern tools; Crocicchia's raw grit feels prehistoric, yet that lone Giants score lingers like a fever dream.

Is Jim Crocicchia in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Jim Crocicchia's not in Canton—his NFL ledger's a single start, 89 yards, one TD amid the Giants' '87 dumpster fire. Hall calls for rings and MVPs, not emergency spot duty, though his Knights explosion (26 TDs) whispers what-if.

What is Jim Crocicchia doing now in 2026?

By 2026, Crocicchia's off the grid—no headlines on broadcasting gigs, business ventures, or charity drives. Faded into civilian life after that '87 Giants blink and Knights fireworks, probably golfing or coaching kids, far from the spotlight that chewed him up quick.

How would Jim Crocicchia perform in today's NFL?

Crocicchia's quick release and Arena League arm (6.7 YPA, 26 TDs) would've feasted under today's pass-happy rules—no bump-and-run, quicker drops. But his 46% NFL completion screams sack bait against zone blitzes; he'd be a gadget guy, not a franchise arm.

How does Jim Crocicchia compare to Eli Manning?

Eli Manning's 59.81 passer rating towers over Crocicchia's measly 7.11 from one grim Giants outing, like comparing two Super Bowls to a single TD in a 3-14 slog. Both Big Blue backups turned starters, but Eli slayed Brady; Jim just dodged Phil Simms' shadow.