All-Time 49ers QBs Ranked: Montana #1, Young #2

Tim Rattay

Retired 7 Years In The NFL
🏆 Louisiana Tech Athletic Hall of Fame (2007)
Tim's
HAIR
9.2
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Tim Rattay or the 49ers?

Tim Rattay Legacy

HEYTC AI
Tim Rattay, the gunslinging Louisiana Tech legend who torched Nebraska for 590 yards in the Eddie Robinson Classic and twice stunned Alabama on their turf, was a college air raid pioneer—still holding the FBS record for career yards per game at 382.4 after rewriting the Bulldogs' books in just three seasons. A seventh-round 49ers steal, he flashed NFL grit as a starter in San Francisco's lean years before bouncing to Tampa and beyond, even hoisting two UFL titles. Now an offensive analyst at LSU after QB-coaching stints with Sanders, Haskins, and Higgins, Rattay's real legacy? Proving pocket poise and deep-ball daring transcend levels.

Tim Rattay Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Average
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
NPC
6 years with the 49ers

Tim Rattay Career Stats via Wikipedia

4,853 Pass Yards
31 Touchdowns
23 INTs
0.0% Comp %
9.2 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Tim Rattay

How does Brock Purdy compare to Tim Rattay?

Tim Rattay's the bridge guy for 49ers fans—solid spot starter with 4,853 yards and 31 TDs in eight seasons, while Brock Purdy's out here building a dynasty run, already with a Super Bowl push and that Mr. Irrelevant magic. Rattay held the fort in dark days post-Montana; Purdy's thriving in Shanahan's machine. One's a gritty survivor, the other's the next-era savior.

Is Tim Rattay in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Tim Rattay's not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no Canton bronze bust for the guy who slung it for the 49ers, Cards, and Bucs with 4,853 yards and 31 TDs over eight years. He's a cult hero for that 38-completion record in '04, but Hall voters chase rings and MVPs, not journeyman grit.

What is Tim Rattay doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Tim Rattay's thriving as an offensive analyst at LSU after five years coaching QBs at Oklahoma State, where he molded guys like Alan Bowman for 3,460 yards in '23. Before that, Commanders gig and LA Tech roots—dude's parlayed his cannon arm into shaping SEC studs alongside old pal Joe Sloan.

How would Tim Rattay perform in today's NFL?

Rattay's quick-release pocket game—think 81.9 rating, 4,853 yards—would feast in today's pass-happy NFL with no-touchdown protections and RPOs everywhere. His Louisiana Tech explosion (12,746 college yards) screams he'd post 4,000-yard seasons, dodging sacks better than in the brutal early-2000s trenches.

How does Tim Rattay compare to Joe Montana?

Rattay's 81.9 career rating pales next to Joe Montana's 95.15 masterpiece, but both 49ers QBs owned Levi's Field in their eras—Joe with four rings, Tim gutting out 2-11 in '04 amid rebuild hell. Montana's the GOAT poet; Rattay's the bar-fight brawler who once tied the Bears in OT for Gruden.