All-Time Buccaneers QBs Ranked: Brady #1, Johnson #2

Casey Weldon

#11 · Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Retired 4 Years In The NFL
🏆 Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award (1991)
Casey's
HAIR
6.2
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Casey Weldon or the Buccaneers?

Casey Weldon Legacy

HEYTC AI
Casey Weldon was the quarterback who made Florida State's offense hum in 1991, a senior leader who commanded respect through poise and precision rather than flash. That year—when he won the Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award—Weldon epitomized the cerebral QB, the kind who understood angles and progressions before most peers. He was a first-team All-American who proved you didn't need a cannon arm to elevate everyone around you. His NFL journey was brief and humbling, a reminder that college excellence doesn't always translate to the pros. But in Tallahassee, Weldon left his mark as a winner who did things the right way, the kind of player Johnny Unitas himself would've admired.

Casey Weldon Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
4 years with the Buccaneers

Casey Weldon Career Stats via Wikipedia

713 Pass Yards
1 Touchdowns
4 INTs
0.0% Comp %
6.2 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Casey Weldon

How does Baker Mayfield compare to Casey Weldon?

Casey Weldon and Baker Mayfield both wore the Bucs' pewter, but that's where the overlap ends—Weldon's three games in '93 netted 76 yards, one TD, and a 22.2 rating before Baker arrived decades later to actually win a Super Bowl. Mayfield's scripting his own Buccaneer epic with arm talent and moxie; Weldon's a footnote, the guy who held the clipboard when it was still a novel idea.

Is Casey Weldon in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, Casey's not in Canton—his 713 yards and lone TD over five seasons didn't exactly scream Hall of Fame. Think about it: the guy's pro ledger fits on a cocktail napkin, while the Hall's packed with ring-kissers and stat monsters. Solid FSU roots with 4,628 college yards, but NFL immortality? Not even close.

What is Casey Weldon doing now in 2026?

As of early 2026, Casey Weldon's off the grid—no splashy broadcasting gigs, no viral charity runs, zilch in business headlines. Last pro blip was Ironman Football League in 2020 with Birmingham, but these days? Probably coaching youth ball or grilling in Tallahassee, the quiet fade for a guy who peaked early at FSU. Search turns up crickets.

How would Casey Weldon perform in today's NFL?

Weldon's quick-release FSU arm might sneak a roster spot today with pass-happy rules and RPOs everywhere, but his '93 accuracy (55%) and that 6.18 career rating scream third-stringer behind the mobile stars. Modern NFL chews up pocket statues without elite zip— he'd be Jameis Winston's emergency Uber, not a starter.

How does Casey Weldon compare to Doug Williams?

Doug Williams lapped Casey Weldon under center for the Bucs—Doug's 38.71 rating and Super Bowl XII ring tower over Weldon's 6.18 disaster across 713 yards. Williams was the trailblazer who broke barriers; Casey, a '92 fifth-rounder, mopped up in mop-up duty. Both franchise QBs? Sure, if "franchise" means alphabetical order.