All-Time Steelers QBs Ranked: Bradshaw #1, Roethlisberger #2

Brian St. Pierre

#2 · Pittsburgh Steelers
Retired 10 Years In The NFL
Brian's
HAIR
0.0
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Brian St. Pierre or the Steelers?

Brian St. Pierre Legacy

HEYTC AI
Brian St. Pierre was the ultimate NFL journeyman—a capable college starter at Boston College who spent eight seasons chasing opportunities he'd never quite get. Drafted by Pittsburgh in 2003, he bounced between the Steelers, Ravens, Cardinals, and Panthers, accumulating just five NFL passes before getting his shot: a November 2010 start for Carolina against Baltimore where he completed 13 of 28 for 173 yards. That single game defined his career—not because he excelled, but because it represented what could have been. St. Pierre embodied the cruel mathematics of professional football: talent enough to stick around, not enough to ever truly break through. His real legacy wasn't measured in statistics; it was in perseverance.

Brian St. Pierre Rating Breakdown

Season
Fantasy
Playoffs
Overall
3 years with the Steelers

Brian St. Pierre Career Stats via Wikipedia

0 Pass Yards
2 Touchdowns
3 INTs
0.0% Comp %

Frequently Asked Questions About Brian St. Pierre

Is Brian St. Pierre in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, St. Pierre's never sniffed Canton—and that's fine by him. He was inducted into Boston College's Varsity Club Hall of Fame recently, which feels more fitting for a guy who spent his NFL career as a perpetual backup, throwing exactly one regular-season pass. His real legacy isn't measured in Pro Football Hall votes; it's in what he's built at St. John's Prep.

What is Brian St. Pierre doing now in 2026?

St. Pierre's been the head coach at St. John's Preparatory School in Danvers, Massachusetts since 2014, a gig he's clearly married to. He's led the Eagles to three Division 1 Super Bowl victories (2018, 2019, 2022) and hasn't missed a practice in 11 years as head coach. He's also an administrator with St. John's Office for Institutional Advancement and has explicitly said he's not leaving high school coaching—turned down NFL and college opportunities because he loves working with that age group.

How would Brian St. Pierre perform in today's NFL?

Hard to say—St. Pierre never got a real shot in his era either. He threw one pass in the regular season across three different teams, so projecting him forward feels academic. What we know: he was a capable backup who couldn't crack rosters loaded with better talent. Modern passing rules might've helped, but his arm never got tested enough to know if he had NFL-caliber accuracy or decision-making.

How does Brian St. Pierre compare to Terry Bradshaw?

Not comparable, really. Bradshaw was a four-time Super Bowl champion and legitimate franchise pillar; St. Pierre was a depth piece who bounced between practice squads. Bradshaw's 81.63 rating reflects actual starting experience and clutch moments. St. Pierre's career was defined by what he didn't do—which tells you everything about why one's in Canton and the other's thriving in high school.