Don Panciera
Questions about Don Panciera or the Cardinals?
Don Panciera Legacy
HEYTC AIDon Panciera Rating Breakdown
Don Panciera Career Stats via Wikipedia
Frequently Asked Questions About Don Panciera
How does Kyler Murray compare to Don Panciera?
Kyler Murray operates in a completely different universe from Don Panciera. Murray's a dual-threat dynamo with MVP hardware and 30,000+ passing yards; Panciera was a journeyman from the early 1950s who threw for 1,383 total yards across multiple leagues. Murray's the face of a modern franchise; Panciera was a stopgap solution who couldn't stick anywhere long-term.
Is Don Panciera in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?
No, Don Panciera never made it to Canton. He was a career backup and journeyman who bounced between the Yankees, Lions, Cardinals, and Toronto Argonauts from 1949-1953. His 36.5% completion rate with the Cardinals tells you everything about his Hall of Fame prospects.
How would Don Panciera perform in today's NFL?
Panciera would've been a backup at best in today's pass-happy NFL. His 5.6 yards per attempt and interception-to-touchdown ratio (25 picks, 11 TDs) would get him benched faster than you can say "analytics". Modern conditioning and coaching might've helped, but his arm talent simply wasn't there—even accounting for era adjustment.
How does Don Panciera compare to Jim Hart?
Jim Hart absolutely dwarfs Panciera in the Cardinals ledger. Hart posted a 34.49 rating compared to Panciera's 7.47, threw for thousands more yards, and actually sustained a career. Hart was a legitimate franchise QB; Panciera was a warm body filling a roster spot during the league's Wild West years.