| Rank | Name | Team | Years | Season | Fantasy | Playoffs | Rating | Overall |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Peyton Manning | Colts | 13 | Great | Elite | Great | 55.6 | Sigma |
| 2 | Johnny Unitas | Colts | 17 | Great | Good | Great | 54.9 | Sigma |
| 3 | Earl Morrall | Colts | 4 | Great | Good | Average | 35.9 | Chill |
| 4 | Andrew Luck | Colts | 6 | Good | Great | Average | 35.9 | Chill |
| 5 | Daniel Jones | Colts | 1 | Good | Great | Average | 32.4 | Chill |
| 6 | Bert Jones | Colts | 9 | Average | Good | Subpar | 30.3 | Delulu |
| 7 | Jim Harbaugh | Colts | 4 | Subpar | Good | Average | 28.9 | Delulu |
| 8 | Philip Rivers | Colts | 1 | Good | Good | Subpar | 27.5 | Delulu |
| 9 | Jack Trudeau | Colts | 8 | Subpar | Subpar | Subpar | 26.8 | Delulu |
| 10 | Carson Wentz | Colts | 1 | Average | Great | Non-Factor | 20.5 | Delulu |
| 11 | Chris Chandler | Colts | 2 | Good | Subpar | Non-Factor | 17.9 | NPC |
| 12 | Gardner Minshew | Colts | 1 | Average | Average | Non-Factor | 17.9 | NPC |
| 13 | Jacoby Brissett | Colts | 4 | Subpar | Good | Non-Factor | 17.8 | NPC |
| 14 | Bill Troup | Colts | 4 | Subpar | Subpar | Non-Factor | 15.1 | NPC |
| 15 | Matt Ryan | Colts | 1 | Non-Factor | Average | Non-Factor | 15.1 | NPC |
| 16 | Mike Pagel | Colts | 4 | Subpar | Subpar | Non-Factor | 15.1 | NPC |
| 17 | Matt Hasselbeck | Colts | 3 | Average | Good | Non-Factor | 12.0 | NPC |
| 18 | Gary Cuozzo | Colts | 4 | Subpar | Good | Non-Factor | 10.9 | NPC |
| 19 | Gary Hogeboom | Colts | 3 | Average | Average | Non-Factor | 10.9 | NPC |
| 20 | Joe Flacco | Colts | 1 | Subpar | Good | Non-Factor | 10.9 | NPC |
| 21 | Anthony Richardson | Colts | 3 | Average | Subpar | Non-Factor | 10.0 | NPC |
| 22 | Craig Erickson | Colts | 1 | Average | Subpar | Non-Factor | 9.7 | NPC |
| 23 | Dan Orlovsky | Colts | 1 | Subpar | Average | Non-Factor | 9.7 | NPC |
| 24 | Don Majkowski | Colts | 2 | Average | Subpar | Non-Factor | 9.7 | NPC |
| 25 | Paul Justin | Colts | 3 | Subpar | Average | Non-Factor | 9.7 | NPC |
| 26 | Brian Hoyer | Colts | 1 | Non-Factor | Average | Non-Factor | 8.8 | Cooked |
| 27 | Fred Enke | Colts | 2 | Subpar | Subpar | Non-Factor | 8.8 | Cooked |
| 28 | Gary Kerkorian | Colts | 3 | Subpar | Subpar | Non-Factor | 8.7 | Cooked |
| 29 | George Shaw | Colts | 4 | Subpar | Subpar | Non-Factor | 8.7 | Cooked |
| 30 | Greg Landry | Colts | 3 | Subpar | Subpar | Non-Factor | 8.7 | Cooked |
| 31 | Jeff George | Colts | 4 | Subpar | Subpar | Non-Factor | 8.7 | Cooked |
| 32 | Marty Domres | Colts | 4 | Subpar | Subpar | Non-Factor | 8.7 | Cooked |
| 33 | Browning Nagle | Colts | 1 | Subpar | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 7.2 | Cooked |
| 34 | Curtis Painter | Colts | 2 | Non-Factor | Subpar | Non-Factor | 7.2 | Cooked |
| 35 | Ed Mioduszewski | Colts | 1 | Non-Factor | Subpar | Non-Factor | 7.2 | Cooked |
| 36 | Josh Freeman | Colts | 1 | Subpar | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 7.2 | Cooked |
| 37 | Kerry Collins | Colts | 1 | Non-Factor | Subpar | Non-Factor | 7.2 | Cooked |
| 38 | Mark Herrmann | Colts | 1 | Subpar | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 7.2 | Cooked |
| 39 | Sam Ehlinger | Colts | 3 | Non-Factor | Subpar | Non-Factor | 7.2 | Cooked |
| 40 | Tom Ramsey | Colts | 1 | Non-Factor | Subpar | Non-Factor | 7.1 | Cooked |
| 41 | Tom Matte | Colts | 1 | Subpar | Subpar | Non-Factor | 7.0 | Cooked |
| 42 | Art Schlichter | Colts | 1 | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 5.8 | Cooked |
| 43 | Blair Kiel | Colts | 1 | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 5.8 | Cooked |
| 44 | Cotton Davidson | Colts | 2 | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 5.8 | Cooked |
| 45 | David Humm | Colts | 1 | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 5.7 | Cooked |
| 46 | George Taliaferro | Colts | 2 | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 5.7 | Cooked |
| 47 | Kelly Holcomb | Colts | 1 | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 5.7 | Cooked |
| 48 | Matt Kofler | Colts | 1 | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 5.7 | Cooked |
| 49 | Mike Kirkland | Colts | 1 | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 5.7 | Cooked |
| 50 | Nick Foles | Colts | 1 | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 5.7 | Cooked |
| 51 | Scott Tolzien | Colts | 2 | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | Non-Factor | 5.7 | Cooked |
All-Time Colts Quarterbacks Rankings
All-Time Colts Quarterbacks Rankings FAQ
Who is the greatest Vikings quarterback of all time in this ranking?
Fran Tarkenton holds the top spot with a rating of 50.7, fueled by his “Good” regular-season consistency, “Elite” fantasy impact, and “Good” playoff performances across 13 seasons, earning him “Sigma” status as the franchise’s enduring legend.
Why does Tommy Kramer rank so highly at #2?
Kramer’s 35.2 rating and “Chill” tag reflect his steady “Average” marks across season, fantasy, and playoffs over 13 years, making him a reliable pillar in Vikings history despite not reaching Tarkenton’s heights—highlighting the value of longevity in a QB-starved franchise.
What does the “Rating” column represent?
The Rating is a numerical composite score assessing a QB’s Vikings tenure, incorporating regular season performance, fantasy value, playoff success, and overall legacy—ranging from Tarkenton’s peak 50.7 down to busts like Shaun Hill at 4.9. See how Viking quarterbacks compare to the Greatest NFL Quarterbacks of All-Time.
What do the “Season,” “Fantasy,” and “Playoffs” columns mean?
These are qualitative tiers rating regular-season excellence (e.g., “Great” for dominant play), fantasy football output (e.g., “Elite” for top scorers), and postseason prowess (e.g., “Elite” for deep runs)—forming the backbone of the overall rating.
Why is Brett Favre only #9 despite his Hall of Fame status?
Favre’s brief 2-year Vikings stint yields a 29.6 rating and “Delulu” tag, with solid “Good” season and fantasy marks but only “Average” playoffs—his magic couldn’t overcome the short sample and lack of deep franchise impact, docking him below long-term grinders like Cousins.
How is this Vikings QB ranking calculated?
The rankings blend quantitative metrics (regular season, fantasy, post-season) with qualitative judgments on playoffs and franchise legacy, creating a holistic score that prioritizes sustained impact over isolated brilliance in purple.
What do the slang terms in the “Overall” column mean (like “Aura,” “Sigma,” or “NPC”)?
These come from our “Dad Glossary” for a fun, informal vibe on team QB vibes:
-
- Aura/Elite: Legendary dominance.
- Sigma/Great: Consistently elite.
- Slaps/Good: Solid performers.
- Chill/Average: Reliable but unflashy.
- Delulu/Mediocre: Overhyped potential without results.
- NPC/Subpar: Forgettable and inconsistent.
- Cooked/Non-Factor: Total busts.
How often is this list updated?
Updates occur throughout the year yet primarily during the NFL post-season and after the Super Bowl to reflect evolving careers, such as J.J. McCarthy and Carson Wentz.