All-Time Broncos QBs Ranked: Elway #1, Manning #2

Bill Musgrave

Denver Broncos
Retired 2 Years In The NFL
🏆 Super Bowl champion (XXIX)
Bill's
HAIR
6.3
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Bill Musgrave or the Broncos?

Bill Musgrave Legacy

HEYTC AI
Bill Musgrave, the gritty Oregon gunslinger from Grand Junction who gutted out a shoulder injury to hurl the game-winning TD against UCLA in '90, etched his name in Duck lore as a three-year captain and first-team All-Pac-10 star, snapping a 26-year bowl drought. A fourth-round pick, he backed up legends Montana, Young, and Elway, snagging a Super Bowl XXIX ring without throwing a pass in it. But Musgrave's real magic unfolded on sidelines, molding Pro Bowlers like Matt Ryan, Steve Beuerlein, and Derek Carr into stars across two decades as QB whisperer and OC. Now tuning arms in Cleveland, he's football's ultimate connector—player to play-caller.

Bill Musgrave Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
2 years with the Broncos

Bill Musgrave Career Stats via Wikipedia

0 Pass Yards
1 Touchdowns
2 INTs
0.0% Comp %
6.3 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Bill Musgrave

How does Bo Nix compare to Bill Musgrave?

Bo Nix has the keys to the Broncos kingdom now, but Bill Musgrave's the ultimate backup blueprint—402 yards, one TD, and a Super Bowl ring holding Elway's clipboard in '95. Nix brings Oregon flash like Musgrave's college days (8,343 Ducks yards), yet Musgrave's '95 relief stints (71.0 rating) set a low bar Nix already laps; guy's got arm talent Musgrave wishes for in spot duty.

Is Bill Musgrave in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Bill Musgrave's not in Canton—no bust for the clipboard hero who backed up Montana, Young, and Elway across 12 games with 402 yards and a single TD. His ring came as a '95 Broncos benchwarmer and '94 Niner, but Hall voters skip the deep reserves, even Oregon legends who own Pac-10 passing marks.

What is Bill Musgrave doing now in 2026?

Bill Musgrave's calling plays as Cleveland Browns quarterbacks coach in 2026, after jumping from Broncos OC to Browns senior offensive assistant in '23. The journeyman guru—27 years coaching QBs and OCs from Raiders to Falcons—now molds Deshaun Watson, trading Denver's altitude for Lake Erie's chill.

How would Bill Musgrave perform in today's NFL?

Musgrave's quick-release pocket game (59.6% Broncos completion, 57.8 passer rating) would've feasted under no-roughing rules and quick outs—think 402 career yards ballooning like vintage backups in Shanahan schemes. But his two INTs in six Denver starts scream turnover-prone in a blitz-happy era; solid role player, not Mahomes 2.0.

How does Bill Musgrave compare to John Elway?

Elway's 71.78 career rating towers over Musgrave's Broncos 6.34 eyesore (31-for-52, 276 yards, two picks), like comparing a Ferrari to a reliable pickup. Both franchise guys, sure, but Musgrave was the '95 emergency brake to Elway's Hall of Fame throttle—ring together, worlds apart in orange crush lore.