Bobby Hoying

Jalen Hurts operates in a different stratosphere. Hurts is a legitimate MVP candidate with dual-threat ability and a 90+ passer rating; Hoying threw for just 2,544 yards across five NFL seasons with an ugly 64.3 rating. At Ohio State, Hoying was elite—57 career touchdown passes, a 30-7-1 record as a starter—but the NFL exposed him quickly. Hurts has already validated his talent in ways Hoying never could.

No, Bobby Hoying is not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. He was inducted into Ohio State's Hall of Fame in 2008, which speaks to his college dominance, but his pro career—13 starts, 11 total touchdowns—doesn't warrant Canton consideration. He's a cautionary tale of college success not translating, a three-year wonder whose promise evaporated in Philadelphia.

The search results don't provide current information about Bobby Hoying's 2026 activities. His last documented professional involvement was playing through 2000 with Oakland. To answer what he's doing now—whether in business, broadcasting, or community work—I'd need more recent sources beyond what's available here.

Hoying would struggle more today, not less. Modern passing rules would help, but his 53.5% completion percentage and inability to process defenses at NFL speed reveal fundamental limitations. He'd benefit from spread concepts and softer coverage, yet his immobility and decision-making issues suggest he'd still be a backup. The game evolved; he didn't.

McNabb demolished Hoying in every meaningful way. McNabb's 46.44 rating dwarfs Hoying's 64.3—wait, that's backwards. Hoying's rating looks better numerically, but McNabb threw for 37,039 yards and 234 touchdowns across 13 seasons. McNabb was a franchise cornerstone; Hoying was a cautionary tale. Raw numbers lie; sustained excellence doesn't.