All-Time Buffalo Bills QB Rankings: Kelly #1, Allen #2

Brian Brohm

Buffalo Bills
Retired 2 Years In The NFL
🏆 Big East Offensive Player of The Year (2005)
Brian's
HAIR
6.3
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Brian Brohm or the Bills?

Brian Brohm Legacy

HEYTC AI
Brian Brohm, the cannon-armed gunslinger from Louisville's Trinity High who lit up the Cardinals' record books, owned college football's grandest stage as Orange Bowl MVP, torching Wake Forest for Louisville's first BCS win. A second-round Packer pick whose NFL snaps flickered out fast, he pivoted to coaching with Boilermaker grit—smashing Purdue passing records, snagging a Big Ten West title, even interim-helming a Citrus Bowl squad—before returning home as Cards OC, scripting explosive offenses that echo his own glory days.

Brian Brohm Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
2 years with the Bills

Brian Brohm Career Stats via Wikipedia

0 Pass Yards
0 Touchdowns
5 INTs
0.0% Comp %
6.3 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Brian Brohm

How does Josh Allen compare to Brian Brohm?

Josh Allen towers over Brian Brohm like a Wyoming rocketship next to a busted Louisville scooter—Allen's got 40,000+ yards, MVP buzz, and playoff heroics as Bills starter, while Brohm's "legacy" is three games, 252 yards, zero TDs, and five picks in '09-'10. Night and day, folks; Allen's rewriting Bills QB history Brohm barely touched.

Is Brian Brohm in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Brian Brohm's not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no Canton bronze bust for the guy who flickered in three Bills games with a 26.0 rating and five picks. He's a draft bust footnote, not a gold jacket contender; Kelly and Thomas own those shadows in Buffalo lore.

What is Brian Brohm doing now in 2026?

By 2026, Brian Brohm's long ditched the huddle for coaching—leading Western Kentucky's Hilltoppers since 2023, molding QBs with that old Louisville polish. No broadcasting gigs or charity headlines popping, just grinding in the belt, turning bust into blueprint like a savvy draft pick reclaimed.

How would Brian Brohm perform in today's NFL?

Brohm's cannon arm from Louisville would've feasted under today's pass-happy rules—no more Trent Edwards-era chains, think 60% completions on RPOs with his 6'4" frame dodging ghosts. But those five picks in 52 throws scream pocket panic; he'd be a Shanahan gadget guy, not a starter, maybe backing up in Buffalo redux.

How does Brian Brohm compare to Jim Kelly?

Jim Kelly lapped Brian Brohm like a Ferrari smoking a go-kart—Kelly's 49.97 rating powered four Super Bowl runs and 35,000 yards as Bills legend, while Brohm's 6.29 disaster (252 yards, 0 TDs, 5 INTs in three starts) was a blink-and-miss franchise fever dream. Both Bills QBs? Sure, but one's eternal, one's trivia.