All-Time Giants QBs Ranked: Manning #1, Simms #2

Charlie Conerly

#42 · New York Giants
Retired 1 Year In The NFL
🏆 NFL champion (1956)
Charlie's
HAIR
25.4
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Charlie Conerly or the Giants?

Charlie Conerly Legacy

HEYTC AI
Charlie Conerly, the lanky Mississippi gunslinger who traded his Ole Miss halfback cleats for a Marine helmet in the Pacific before transforming a dismal Giants squad into contenders, was pro football's quiet gunslinger with ice-water veins. What made "Chuckin' Charlie" special? A rookie season for the ages in '48, that flawless 152.1-rated masterpiece dismantling the Bears 47-7 for New York's first title in 18 years, and torching records into his 40s—outdueling legends when it mattered most. Steady as sunrise, he embodied Giant grit, his No. 42 forever ringed in honor. Conerly passed away in 1996, leaving a legacy etched in championship lore.
Charlie Conerly passed away on February 13, 1996 at the age of 74.

Charlie Conerly Rating Breakdown

Season
Good
Fantasy
Average
Playoffs
Subpar
Overall
Delulu
1 year with the Giants

Charlie Conerly Career Stats via Wikipedia

19,488 Pass Yards
173 Touchdowns
167 INTs
0.0% Comp %
25.4 HAIR
63-37 Record

Frequently Asked Questions About Charlie Conerly

How does Jaxson Dart compare to Charlie Conerly?

Jaxson Dart's got big shoes to fill stepping in as Giants starter—Charlie Conerly slung 19,488 yards and 173 TDs over 14 seasons, ranking third all-time in touchdowns at retirement, with a .647 winning percentage topping 16 Hall of Famers like Jim Kelly. Dart's flash is fun, but Conerly's leather-helmet grit built the blueprint; kid needs a decade of wins to touch that.

Is Charlie Conerly in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, Charlie Conerly's not in Canton, despite those giant accomplishments like eight winning seasons and a 1961 relief masterpiece—three TDs, zero picks, 129.2 rating to clinch the East. His 173 TDs trailed only Baugh and Layne at retirement, yet the Hall snubbed him. Tough break for a two-time Pro Bowler and champ.

How would Charlie Conerly perform in today's NFL?

Conerly would feast in today's pass-happy NFL—modern rules nix the mugging of receivers he endured, and his college arm (nation-leading completions, efficiency in '47) plus pinpoint accuracy translated to 173 pro TDs. That .647 win rate? Imagine him with RPOs and no contact drills. He'd be a top-15 guy, not just Giants lore.

How does Charlie Conerly compare to Eli Manning?

Eli Manning lapped Conerly in raw stats—59.81 passer rating to Charlie's 25.41—but both owned the Giants pocket like brothers. Conerly's 57-31-1 record (.647) and '59 MVP outshine Eli's two rings in clutch gene; think of Charlie as the black-and-white Eli, tougher defenses be damned, with TDs third all-time back then.