All-Time Browns QBs Ranked: Graham #1, Kosar #2

Connor Shaw

#9 · Cleveland Browns
Retired 1 Year In The NFL
Connor's
HAIR
6.1
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Connor Shaw or the Browns?

Connor Shaw Legacy

HEYTC AI
Connor Shaw, the gritty South Carolina gunslinger from Flowery Branch, Georgia, etched his name in Gamecock lore as the winningest starter ever at 27-5, a perfect 17-0 at home. What defined him? Pure gamer instinct—limping off the bench with a sprained knee and illness to orchestrate a 17-point fourth-quarter miracle against No. 5 Missouri in double OT, then capping his college run with a Capital One Bowl MVP masterpiece: throwing, running, and catching TDs in a 312-yard clinic. Thrust into the NFL spotlight as Cleveland's emergency starter versus Baltimore in 2014, he slung a 49-yard dart amid chaos, embodying the underdog heart that later fueled his coaching gigs back at Carolina.

Connor Shaw Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
1 year with the Browns

Connor Shaw Career Stats via Wikipedia

0 Pass Yards
0 Touchdowns
1 INTs
50.0% Comp %
6.1 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Connor Shaw

How does Shedeur Sanders compare to Connor Shaw?

Shedeur Sanders, the Browns' current gunslinger starter, flashes NFL polish with his arm talent, but Connor Shaw's one gritty 2014 start—177 yards, no picks after the first, legs churning for tough yards—carries that underdog legacy Shedeur's still chasing. Shaw's 55.2 rating in chaos feels like the Browns' eternal audition tape; Shedeur's got the tools, but Connor owned that lone spotlight.

Is Connor Shaw in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, Connor Shaw's not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no Canton bronze bust for the South Carolina scrapper who went 14-of-28 for 177 yards in his one Browns start back in 2014. Hall's for the Ottos and Joes; Shaw's the cult hero who fumbled a punt return but scrambled like hell. Deserves a beer league plaque, though.

What is Connor Shaw doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Connor Shaw's out of the spotlight, likely grinding in coaching gigs or business after that lone Browns cameo—no headlines on broadcasting or charity empires. Picture him at some high school clinic in Georgia, barking dual-threat wisdom from his college days, or selling insurance with tales of sacking Manziel's backups. Football's rearview now.

How would Connor Shaw perform in today's NFL?

Connor Shaw's legs and grit would spark in today's pass-happy NFL—think gadget plays under modern rules protecting QBs—but his 50% completion and zero-TD arm wouldn't start anywhere but maybe a wildcat wrinkle. Rushing for 9 yards on 7 carries in 2014? Coaches would scheme it like Lamar lite, but he'd be a camp curiosity, not a franchise face.

How does Connor Shaw compare to Otto Graham?

Otto Graham's 62.63 rating towers over Connor Shaw's 55.2 like the Rock over a peewee—Otto threw TDs for breakfast in the Browns' glory '40s-'50s, while Shaw's single 2014 start was a survival scramble. Both franchise QBs? Sure, if you squint; Graham built empires, Connor's the trivia answer for "Who started after Manziel?"