All-Time Buffalo Bills QB Rankings: Kelly #1, Allen #2

Dan Darragh

Buffalo Bills
Retired 3 Years In The NFL
🏆 William & Mary Athletics Hall of Fame
Dan's
HAIR
12.1
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Dan Darragh or the Bills?

Dan Darragh Legacy

HEYTC AI
Dan Darragh was a William & Mary star who arrived in Buffalo during the AFL's final days, a tall, confident arm who never quite found his footing in the pros. His three seasons with the Bills were a study in hard luck—a 30.4 passer rating that tells you everything about a quarterback caught between eras, learning on the job against defenses that ate him alive. He wasn't the guy, and he knew it, but he showed up, competed, and moved on with grace. Darragh passed away last September at 78, leaving behind the memory of a college hero who gave the NFL his shot and took his lumps like a pro.
Dan Darragh passed away on September 2, 2025 at the age of 78.

Dan Darragh Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
NPC
3 years with the Bills

Dan Darragh Career Stats via Wikipedia

1,353 Pass Yards
4 Touchdowns
22 INTs
42.9% Comp %
12.1 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Dan Darragh

How does Josh Allen compare to Dan Darragh?

Josh Allen's a walking highlight reel, torching defenses for 4,000-yard seasons and MVP chatter, while Dan Darragh's three-year Bills stint netted 1,353 yards and four TDs amid a grim 3-26-1 stretch—think Allen's cannon arm versus Darragh's scrappy college flash that fizzled against AFL beasts. Legacy? Allen's rewriting Bills lore; Darragh's a footnote gunslinger.

Is Dan Darragh in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, Dan Darragh never sniffed Canton—no bust, no gold jacket, just a brief Bills backup turned starter in '68 after Jack Kemp's injury, posting 1,353 yards over three AFL/NFL seasons before fading. Hall's for guns like Unitas; Darragh's the guy who punted and scrambled but couldn't sustain the spark.

How would Dan Darragh perform in today's NFL?

Darragh's quick-release college arm—1,346 yards, 14 TDs at Richmond—might snag a practice squad nod today with pass-happy rules and RPOs everywhere, but his 12-ish rating and 14 picks in '68 scream turnover machine against zone blitzes. Fun gadget guy, maybe, not a 53-man lock in this speed era.

How does Dan Darragh compare to Jim Kelly?

Jim Kelly's 49.97 rating and playoff gunslinging tower over Darragh's puny 12.09 mark from the same Bills threads—Kelly engineered AFC title games, Darragh sparked a few '68 wins post-Kemp injury but went 3-26-1 overall. Both franchise QBs? Kelly's the opera; Darragh's the warm-up act with punting chops.