All-Time Colts QBs Ranked: Manning #1, Unitas #2

David Humm

#11 · Indianapolis Colts
Retired 1 Year In The NFL
🏆 2× Super Bowl champion (XI, XVIII)
David's
HAIR
6.1
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about David Humm or the Colts?

David Humm Legacy

HEYTC AI
David Humm was the cool-handed gunslinger from Las Vegas, nicknamed "The Dealer" for his uncanny touch—ripping off a Husker-record 15 straight completions against Kansas in '74, cementing his status as Nebraska's finest QB of his era with All-American shine and a national title ring. Fifth-round pick who bounced from Raiders to Bills to Colts, Humm etched his name on two Lombardi Trophies (XI and XVIII), thriving as the ultimate Raider insurance policy amid the silver-and-black dynasty. A quiet winner who dealt perfection when it counted most. Humm passed away in 2018 at 65, leaving a legacy of grit and glory.
David Humm passed away on March 27, 2018 at the age of 65.

David Humm Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
1 year with the Colts

David Humm Career Stats

Statistics are being loaded. Check back soon.

Frequently Asked Questions About David Humm

How does Daniel Jones compare to David Humm?

Daniel Jones, your current Colts starter, looks like a Ferrari next to David Humm's trusty pickup truck—Jones has flashed real arm talent and mobility in Indy, while Humm's career was a journeyman's 753 yards, 3 TDs over a decade backing up legends on Raiders and Colts squads that snagged two rings. Humm's the ultimate trivia answer, not the franchise driver.

Is David Humm in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, David Humm never made it to Canton—his ledger shows 753 passing yards, 3 touchdowns, and a couple rings as a backup across Raiders, Colts, and Bills from '75-'84. Hall's for the stars who carried teams; Humm was the reliable clipboard holder who cashed winner's checks without the spotlight.

How would David Humm perform in today's NFL?

Humm's old-school game—quick feet from his Nebraska days, smart reads in run-first eras—might snag him third-string today with pass-happy rules letting QBs air it out sans fear. But 63-of-137 career comps for 753 yards screams "practice squad fodder" against these rocket-arm kids slinging 400-yarders weekly.

How does David Humm compare to Peyton Manning?

Peyton Manning lapped the planet with a 55.59 passer rating on the Colts; Humm limped to 6.07 sprinkling 753 yards lifetime as a backup Raider/Colt. Both wore Horseshoe blue, but Peyton sculpted Mount Rushmore while Humm was the guy holding the clipboard during those Super Bowl parades—pure depths-of-roster poetry.