All-Time Panthers QBs Ranked: Delhomme #1, Newton #2

Derek Anderson

Retired 13 Years In The NFL
🏆 Pro Bowl (2007)
Derek's
HAIR
11.0
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Derek Anderson or the Panthers?

Derek Anderson Legacy

HEYTC AI
Derek Anderson, the lanky Oregon farm kid who turned late-round afterthought into Cleveland's fleeting savior, lived for chaos. Snatched 213th in '05, he seized the Browns' reins in '07, unleashing a five-TD barrage on Cincy in a 51-45 shootout—only the third time NFL QBs traded five-packs in one game, edging Carson Palmer's six. He dragged the Browns to 10-6, snagged a Pro Bowl nod as Brady's injury sub, and ranked among Cleveland's top QBs for nearly a decade. Backup wizard later, Anderson hoisted a Lombardi with Carolina's practice squad in Super Bowl 50, proving heart trumps hype every time.

Derek Anderson Rating Breakdown

Season
Average
Fantasy
Average
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
NPC
7 years with the Panthers

Derek Anderson Career Stats via Wikipedia

10,878 Pass Yards
60 Touchdowns
64 INTs
54.3% Comp %
11.0 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Derek Anderson

How does Bryce Young compare to Derek Anderson?

Bryce Young’s got big shoes to fill stepping into Derek Anderson’s old Panthers gig, where DA went 2-5 as starter but slung 10,878 yards and 60 TDs career-wide, peaking with that wild 5-TD explosion vs. Cincy in ’07. Young’s quick release and smarts echo Anderson’s cannon arm, but he’ll need DA’s gunslinger grit to match that 10-5 Browns heater—Panthers fans still whisper about it.

Is Derek Anderson in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Derek Anderson’s not in Canton—zero bust waiting there despite that lone Pro Bowl nod as a Brady injury fill-in and a Most Improved Player tag after his 29-TD ’07 breakout. With 60 TDs against 64 picks and a 70.4 rating over 13 seasons, he was a sixth-round surprise who lit up scoreboards but never Hall-level consistent.

What is Derek Anderson doing now in 2026?

As of early 2026, Derek Anderson’s chilling out of the spotlight, no big broadcasting gigs or charity headlines popping—last we saw, he wrapped his NFL days as a backup with the Bills in 2019. Guy’s probably coaching youth ball or grilling burgers in Oregon, savoring that one magical Browns year like a ’07 tattoo nobody else gets.

How would Derek Anderson perform in today's NFL?

Anderson’s bazooka arm and 6’6” frame would feast in today’s pass-happy NFL—think those deep bombs to Kellen Winslow thriving under no-touch rules, maybe a poor man’s Geno Smith. His 54% completion and 70.4 rating scream turnover trouble in this RPO era, but he’d carve secondaries like that 51-45 Bengals thriller.

How does Derek Anderson compare to Jake Delhomme?

Jake Delhomme owned the Panthers soul with a 39.42 rating and NFC Championship magic, while Derek Anderson’s 70.4 mark across stints there felt more like a rental—solid yards but pick-prone chaos. Delhomme was the steady road warrior; DA, the boom-or-bust cannon who torched Cincy for five scores but faded fast.