All-Time Packers QBs Ranked: Starr #1, Rodgers #2

Jerry Tagge

#8 · Green Bay Packers
Retired 3 Years In The NFL
Jerry's
HAIR
8.6
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Jerry Tagge or the Packers?

Jerry Tagge Legacy

HEYTC AI
Jerry Tagge was a winner before he was a pro—the kind of quarterback who made Nebraska hum in the early '70s, steering the Cornhuskers to back-to-back national championships with a blend of precision and grit that earned him second-team All-American honors. In the NFL, though, the fit was never quite right. A first-round pick by Green Bay in '72, Tagge couldn't replicate that college magic in the pros, battling injuries and inconsistency in a crowded quarterback room. He found better footing in the CFL, where he earned a Jeff Nicklin Trophy nod in 1977. His legacy lives in Lincoln, not Green Bay—a reminder that college dominance doesn't always translate, but it never diminishes what you accomplished when it mattered most.

Jerry Tagge Rating Breakdown

Season
Average
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
3 years with the Packers

Jerry Tagge Career Stats via Wikipedia

1,583 Pass Yards
0 Touchdowns
0 INTs
0.0% Comp %
8.6 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Jerry Tagge

How does Jordan Love compare to Jerry Tagge?

Jordan Love has the arm talent and mobility to be Green Bay's guy for a decade, while Jerry Tagge's three-year Packer stint—1,583 yards, 3 TDs, 26.7 rating—faded fast behind Starr and Kemp. Love's already got more starts and zip; Tagge was a Husker hero with national rings, but NFL? Love laps that legacy like a Ferrari passing a Pinto.

Is Jerry Tagge in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Jerry Tagge's not in Canton—no bust waiting for him alongside the Packers greats. His pro line was thin: 1,583 yards, 3 TDs over three seasons, buried behind Bart Starr's shadow. Husker legend with back-to-back nattys? Sure. But NFL immortality? That's for the ice men, not the '70s benchwarmers.

What is Jerry Tagge doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Tagge's long retired from the gridiron, keeping a low profile after stints in broadcasting and USFL days. No big headlines on business ventures or charity drives lately—he's that quiet Nebraska legend sipping coffee, reminiscing about Orange Bowl plunges over Alabama, while the NFL world spins without him.

How would Jerry Tagge perform in today's NFL?

Tagge's quick-release Husker accuracy—57-61% completion, 1,300+ yards a pop—might carve a backup niche today with pass-happy rules and no bump-and-run thugs. But his arm wasn't cannon-like, and 10 picks in '72? Modern defenses would snack on that. Think journeyman like Case Keenum, not starter material.

How does Jerry Tagge compare to Bart Starr?

Bart Starr's 64.74 rating and five titles tower over Tagge's Packers whimper—8.58 rating, 1,583 yards, lost in the post-Lombardi fog. Starr was surgical in the Ice Bowl; Tagge, a college stud (#18 on HeyTC's All-Time list), got Packers scraps. Like comparing Sinatra to a wedding singer—both croon, but one's eternal.