All-Time Eagles QBs Ranked: Hurts #1, McNabb #2

Joe Pisarcik

#7 · Philadelphia Eagles
Retired 8 Years In The NFL
Joe's
HAIR
8.5
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Joe Pisarcik or the Eagles?

Joe Pisarcik Legacy

HEYTC AI
Joe Pisarcik was a journeyman quarterback who arrived in New York as a forgettable afterthought and left as a historical footnote—though not the kind he'd have chosen. His Giants tenure was defined by futility: 44.5% completion rate, 18 touchdowns against 43 interceptions, a quarterback so overmatched that even victory was denied him. But Pisarcik's true legacy crystallizes in one November afternoon in 1978, when a handoff that wasn't his call became the play that changed football forever. "The Fumble" to Giants fans, "The Miracle at the Meadowlands" to Eagles fans—it was so catastrophic that it made the quarterback kneel a permanent strategy. He'd find modest success later as a backup in Philadelphia, but nothing erased that moment. Sometimes a career is defined not by what you accomplish, but by what you inadvertently teach the game.

Joe Pisarcik Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
5 years with the Eagles

Joe Pisarcik Career Stats via Wikipedia

0 Pass Yards
24 Touchdowns
48 INTs
0.0% Comp %
8.5 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Joe Pisarcik

How does Jalen Hurts compare to Joe Pisarcik?

Jalen Hurts is etching Eagles immortality with Super Bowl runs and dual-threat fireworks, while Joe Pisarcik's a gritty backup from the '80s grind—5,552 yards, 24 TDs over eight seasons, mostly holding for Ron Jaworski. Hurts builds a legend; Pisarcik's the reliable clip from grainy Vet highlights, no Lombardi shadows.

Is Joe Pisarcik in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Joe Pisarcik's not in Canton—his 53.9 passer rating and that infamous Giants fumble (Miracle at the Meadowlands) keep him out of the Hall. Solid journeyman with Eagles and Giants, 24 TDs in eight years, but no bust awaits. He's remembered more for handoffs gone wrong than glory.

What is Joe Pisarcik doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Pisarcik's long retired from the gridiron, living quietly in Jersey roots after bouncing from Giants to Eagles '80-'84. No headlines on broadcasting gigs or charity drives—just a New Mexico State alum enjoying life post-CFL and NFL, far from the spotlight of his 5,552-yard career.

How would Joe Pisarcik perform in today's NFL?

Pisarcik's arm—54% completion, 53.9 rating—might carve a backup niche today with pass-happy rules and RPOs, but 48 picks scream turnover machine in a league that punishes mistakes. Think journeyman like Case Keenum: spot starts, no franchise savior, thriving more on grit than Hurts-level zip.

How does Joe Pisarcik compare to Ron Jaworski?

Jaworski lapped Pisarcik as Eagles QB1—38.01 rating to Joe's measly 8.53 in spots, with Ron slinging 22,000+ yards while Joe backed him up post-Giants trade. Jaws was the Vet maestro; Pisarcik the clipboard deputy with 24 TDs total. Both Philly tough, but one's a radio king, other's a footnote.