Kerry Collins

Dart's got the athleticism Collins never possessed—the kid's mobile, arm talent looks elite in flashes, and Brian Daboll's clearly building around his upside. Collins was a gunslinger who'd sling it into traffic; Dart's learning to manage the game first. Early returns suggest Dart could be what the Giants hoped Collins would become: a franchise cornerstone rather than a journeyman savior.

No, Collins never made Canton, and honestly, the Hall voters got this one right. Despite that magical 2000 Super Bowl run, his career numbers don't stack up—40,922 yards and 208 TDs spread across too many mediocre seasons. He was a winner when it mattered most, but not a Hall of Famer.

The search results don't provide current information about Collins's 2026 activities, so I can't speak to what he's doing now with authority. Given his broadcasting appearances in past years, he may be involved in media, but I'd need more recent sources to confirm his current work.

Collins would struggle in today's pass-happy NFL. His completion percentage hovered around 60% in an era with shorter routes and easier reads. Modern defenses, coverage schemes, and the emphasis on efficiency would expose his inconsistency. He'd need a loaded roster and a genius coordinator to survive—basically, he'd need 2000 all over again.

It's not even close. Manning's 85-63 record and two Super Bowl rings dwarf Collins's resume, and their efficiency gap is massive—Manning's 59.81 rating versus Collins's 31.7 tells you everything about sustained excellence versus one magical season. Manning was a franchise quarterback; Collins was a franchise savior for one glorious year.