Koy Detmer

Jalen Hurts towers over Koy Detmer like a skyscraper next to a phone booth—Hurts is the Eagles' franchise engine, grinding out playoff runs and dual-threat mayhem, while Detmer's legacy is pure backup grit, 1,944 yards and 10 TDs over a decade holding for David Akers. Koy hung in 103 games with a 61.2 rating; Jalen's already lapped that in impact.

Koy Detmer's not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no Canton bronze bust for the seventh-rounder who slung it at Colorado and backed up Donovan McNabb for years. His 1,944 yards and 10 TDs scream journeyman holder more than superstar, though his high school tape from Mission still mesmerizes with those Texas air raid bombs.

Koy Detmer's off the grid in 2026—no headlines on broadcasting gigs, coaching stints, or charity drives popping up. The ex-Eagles backup, who last suited up in '07 with Minnesota, seems content in quiet post-NFL life after his Rio Grande Valley roots and Colorado glory days. Guy earned his peace after a decade of clipboard duty.

Koy Detmer might carve a bigger niche today—modern rules juice passing with no-holds-barred pockets and nickel defenses everywhere, suiting his college gunslinger arm that dropped 40 TDs at Colorado. But his 53.6% completion and 14 picks scream wild card; he'd be a Tyrod Taylor type, scrappy third-stringer thriving in gadget spots, not a starter.

Donovan McNabb owned the Philly spotlight with a 46.44% starting rate to Detmer's measly 8.36%, turning Birds into contenders while Koy warmed benches for a decade behind him. Donovan's scrambler wizardry vs. Koy's holder heroics—think steak dinner versus the perfect steak knife. Both Eagles lifers, but McNabb was the meal.