All-Time Chiefs QBs Ranked: Mahomes #1, Dawson #2

Matt Cassel

Retired 14 Years In The NFL
🏆 Pro Bowl (2010)
Matt's
HAIR
26.8
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Matt Cassel or the Chiefs?

Matt Cassel Legacy

HEYTC AI
Matt Cassel, the ultimate football survivor, seventh-round afterthought from USC who walked on with Carson Palmer and Matt Leinart, then grinded his way up Bill Belichick's depth chart to become a Patriot. His '08 lightning bolt—stepping in for an injured Tom Brady, going 11-5 with a stat line no QB had ever matched—proved backups can steal the show, even if playoffs dodged him. Traded to KC for a second-rounder, he revived the Chiefs, snagged a Pro Bowl nod, and journeymaned through seven teams with unflappable poise. Cassel's legacy? The gold standard for "what if" QBs who maximized every snap.

Matt Cassel Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Good
Playoffs
Subpar
Overall
Delulu
4 years with the Chiefs

Matt Cassel Career Stats via Wikipedia

17,508 Pass Yards
104 Touchdowns
82 INTs
58.8% Comp %
26.8 HAIR
36-45 Record

Frequently Asked Questions About Matt Cassel

How does Patrick Mahomes compare to Matt Cassel?

Patrick Mahomes has lapped Matt Cassel's Chiefs tenure like a Ferrari passing a reliable pickup—Mahomes owns three rings and MVP hardware since taking over in 2018, while Cassel went 29-18 from 2009-12 with 17,508 yards and that sneaky Pro Bowl nod in a pass-happy year. Legacy? Cassel's the bridge guy who kept the engine warm; Mahomes rebuilt the damn highway.

Is Matt Cassel in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Matt Cassel's not in Canton—no bust waiting for him alongside the Len Dawsons of the world. His journeyman run—backup to Brady, solid Chiefs starter, then Vikings, Titans, Lions—netted 104 TDs but never the sustained elite play for Hall voters. Even ESPN's Schefter overlooked him in the 2024 first-timers list. Solid pro, zero gold jacket.

What is Matt Cassel doing now in 2026?

At 43 in 2026, Matt Cassel's holding court on the Bobby Bones Show, dishing NFL takes like a retired gunslinger at the saloon—reacting to Tomlin's exit and playoff chaos. He popped up on X offering to sling it for the injured Mahomes in '25's final games, arm loose, but it's mostly mic work now after NBC gigs on Big Ten and Notre Dame.

How would Matt Cassel perform in today's NFL?

Cassel's quick release and smarts would feast in today's no-holds-barred passing NFL—think friendlier refs, RPOs galore suiting his USC mobility. That 2009 Pro Bowl season (4,016 yards) previews it; he'd carve up zones like he did defenses then, maybe sniffing 4,000 yards yearly as a bridge starter. Age aside, rules tilt his way big time.

How does Matt Cassel compare to Len Dawson?

Len Dawson's the Chiefs legend at 51.37 passer rating with rings and AFL glory, while Cassel's 26.77 over four Arrowhead years feels like the backup singer to Dawson's headliner—29 wins, sure, but no playoffs juice. Both franchise QBs, yet Dawson's the Hall guy who defined eras; Cassel just kept the seat hot post-Herm Edwards.